• Anonymous

    Vanessa is the prettiest. Ashley isn’t hot by any
    means. Neither of them do it for me to be honest.

  • A.

    Ashley’s wearing some lovely Christian Louboutins<333

  • Mary-Kimberley

    Ashley is my fave but Vanessa does look better.

  • Solange

    I think Ashley’s nose is getting better everyday. Eventhough i miss her old nose but i’m getting used to her new one now. It’s not that bad. As fas as she feels comfortable, we fans are happy.

    Ashley looks gorgeous, her dress’s color seems to be more elegant!

  • http://hihi sarahi

    switch dresses…!! ashley would look better with vanessa’s dress..& vanessa would look better with ashley’s dress..!

  • Anonymous

    obviously VANESSA
    i love both
    buut vanessa is more hot:D

  • Aly

    Ashley!! Always!! she’s so pretty, vanessa is so UGLY, people belive vanessa is pretty cuz’ of make up! but come on guys! look at her!WAKE UP!!

  • jenn

    wow , vanessa has AMAZING style !

  • angelika

    vanessa.

  • Anonymous

    They look really average to me maybe they look better in person.

  • karla

    oh damn! vanessa is sooo flat!!!…she dosent have any boobs in that ugly dress!, at least she should put something:S

  • Steph

    Beautiful!

  • dbhfkjhalkjd

    i hated the blond yet i love the brown!

  • Nikki

    OMG!
    wtf? Vanessa is freakin STUNNING!!!!!!!!!!!
    she is the PRETTIEST woman goin in HOLLYWOOD!
    lol i h8 her shes SOOOO STUNNNNING!
    Ashley needs 2 get her nose FiXed again and her blonde hair BACK!
    luv u Baby V! x x x x

  • joyce

    ew vanessas feet are ugly as hell.

  • Jane

    vanessa is way prettier

  • James

    ASHLEY AND NESSA LOOK AMAZING!!

  • ZzZ

    Oh c’mon!!! They’re BFFs!!! Has it ever occurred to you guys that if you say something bad about one of them then the other one will get hurt too??? Or you’re just too shallow to figure that out??

  • Anonymous

    DEFF. ASHLEY!
    i thought vanessa died,srsly.
    she needs to(:

    ashley is not a slut like vanessa,mmkay??
    atleastttt ash iz COVERED UP
    not like v,SHOWING everything out.
    got it? good(:

  • Anonymous

    I like Ashley’s dress better, but I love Vanessa’s shoes

  • http://www.ashleymtisdale.org B
  • mary

    i love both of them

  • sharmaine

    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!

  • sharmaine

    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!
    VANESSA IS WAY PRETTIER THAN ASHLEY….!!!

  • lol

    they both look good
    but ash is better hers is more elgant
    vanessa’s is more of a thing u wear jus to go walk around outside r sumthing

  • Anonymous

    Vanessa is beautiful. She has NATURAL BEAUTY, she
    doesn’t need makeup to look gorgeous unlike Ashley.

  • Krystal

    ASHLEY TISDALE OWNS VANEXXXA HUDGENS …

  • Anonymous

    ashley!!!

    vanessa’s dress is ugly

  • Solange

    Vanxxxa really has no taste of fashion. How could she wear something so trashy to an event. Ashley is wayyy more mature and way more elegant than that slutty whore. She’s so rude to her fans! Vanxxxa should die!

  • hmarlyn

    HELL NO ASHLEY IS WAY BETTER THAN VANESSA SHE IS A SLUP FUKKEN BITCH DONT EVEN FUKKEN HAVE TIME FOR NOBODY!!! CAN EVEN GET NEW CLOTHE

  • Anonymous

    I love V and Ash!
    They’re both gorgeous :)

  • jojo

    vanessa pulled it off. but then again she looks
    stunning in everything. girl has style and not just
    in this event at at almost every event she goes to.

    vanessa def. wins this one.

  • Anonymous

    Ashley is gorgeous! But so is V. I love Ashley’s dress more though, the back is so pretty!

  • http://ahha.com anna

    ashley used to be so much cuter back in 2006.
    she was super cute & so was vanessa, SOOO pretty.

    2006 > now.

    but if i had to choose i’d say vanessa

  • lala_girl

    uhm…
    I love them both, BUT I think Ashley is the
    prettiest and the one who knows how to dress up fancy
    and glamorous to this kind of event.

    VANESSA, I could wear that dress to the beach
    or a play date for that matter! EVEN I dress up WAY
    better than you do! SHAME ON YOU, girl.

    this dress was so NOT HOT for this event.

  • Sidrah B

    Vanessa is so SOO PRETTY!!!
    Ashlee is gtting there…BLONDE HAIR BACKKK!!!

  • Anonymous

    vanessa looks sooooooooooooooo
    UUUUUUUUUUGGGGGGGGGGGLLLLLLLLLLLYYYYYYYYYY!!

  • d

    ashley is ugly.
    vanessa is gorgeous but looks better w/o the bangs-her face is too pretty to be covered up like that.

  • http://oceanup.com/ jonaslover1

    they both look pretty! but i still think ash tizzy lukz beta wiv her sharpay hair luk!

    =)

  • jonas

    gorgeous both of them!!

  • Anonymous


    check out
    http://WWW.LUV2LUVJONAS.COM

    Check out the site if you’re a Jonas Brothers fan!
    Thanks!

  • sIDRAH b again…

    Both dress r ugly BUT VANESSA IS ALWAYS PRETTY!!!
    ashlee looks really tired in tyhe picture :/

  • lala_girl

    uhm…
    I love them both, BUT I think Ashley is the
    prettiest and the one who knows how to dress up fancy
    and glamorous to this kind of event.

    VANESSA, I could wear that dress to the beach
    or a play date for that matter! EVEN I dress up WAY
    better than you do! SHAME ON YOU, girl.

    this dress was so NOT HOT for this event.

  • sophie

    i like the front ashelys dress, i dont like the back…no one wants to see her bra!! vanessa’s dress is not elegant…its super casual, but she always pulls everything off cause she’s just too pretty ;)

  • christina

    i have an lg rumor :)

  • Anonymous

    vanessa is prettier!!!!!!!!!

  • Anonymous

    vanessa a SLUT and ashley didnt have nude pic so i HATE VANESSA AND LOVE ASHLEY, plus ashley shoes are waaaaaaaay better so suck that

  • KIRBS

    they both look great! I think that it’s funny that the pose that vanessa makes in her first picture and the pose that ashley makes in her first picture are the same poses they made in the picture they were both in (at the top)! idk, just seems a little weird.

  • Anonymous

    they both look GORGEOUS!!

  • http://youtube.com/gotjesus13 mileyluver1393

    vanessa!!
    i love her hair and dress and shoes
    soo cute ashleys dress is ugly

  • Anonymous

    WHY DOES THAT RANDOM COMMENT KEEP POPPING UP OUTTA NOWHERE ?! does someone REALLY waste their time everyday to put that there ?! or is it some random sponsor from oceanup . . .

  • Anonymous

    ashley got REALLY ugly since the nose job . . . just saying . she used to look so pretty .

  • Anonymous

    ASHLEY IS WAY PRETTIER THAN VANESSA….!!!
    ASHLEY IS WAY PRETTIER THAN VANESSA….!!!
    ASHLEY IS WAY PRETTIER THAN VANESSA….!!!
    ASHLEY IS WAY PRETTIER THAN VANESSA….!!!
    ASHLEY IS WAY PRETTIER THAN VANESSA….!!!
    ASHLEY IS WAY PRETTIER THAN VANESSA….!!!
    ASHLEY IS WAY PRETTIER THAN VANESSA….!!!
    ASHLEY IS WAY PRETTIER THAN VANESSA….!!!
    isn’t that annoying?
    and you’re so off, ashleys so much better than vanessa. i like both of them thouqh :)