Selena & The Scene Falling Down Acoustic

The rest of Selena‘s LIVE CHAT September 16 under!

  • alison

    wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t amazing either.
    her band’s funny though. i like greg and ethan.

  • WeWantDemiBackInArgentina

    The live chat was SO DAMN FUNNY! I loved it :D Her band members are amazinggg!

  • CMB

    She does pretty good….its just weird to hear her sing without all the double voice recorded sound

  • suhvanuhh

    You know what sucks?
    People who have real talent at singing and they never get a record deal.
    But people who are okay at it, get to have one just because there signed with Disney.

  • Brenda giiiiirrrrllll

    No, Selena and Miley sound NOTHING Alike… WHAT SO EVER!
    Diffecence number one: Miley can stay on pitch even in fast songs, selena is struggling to stay on pitch in just these few notes. BTW, this song is actually pretty monotone.

    Difference number 2: Mileys voice is powerful, Selenas vice is quiet as a mouse.

    Difference number 3: Miley is talented, Selena is not. She really needs to stick to acting because she will NEVER win a music award!

  • syngates

    i love sleena and all, but her voice is ffllaatt…but she still awsomee and this song is great and her band mates seems cool, but its her band that makes her look good.
    w.e i think she should stick ot act..
    but still i love the girl.

  • PROUD TO BE SAMMIE BROFLOVSKI!

    My god.
    I think that is the worst thing I have ever heard.
    Ever.

  • Anonymous

    was that a joke?

  • Anonymouse

    Bad.

  • egads!

    what the hell was that noise at like 1:46?! a dying cat?

  • peters answers does not work he makes me angry

    i love selena gomez she is awesome but i really wanted to see the drummer belly dance and i wanted to here the joke

  • Ashleyxo

    She hit a couple bad notes but other than that, I like the acoustic version better than the original but I think her voice still needs some work.

  • Anonymousssss

    She isn’t very good.

  • Brenda giiiiirrrrllll

    it just sucks so much that there are so many talented people out there trying to get record deals and this girl who cannot stay on key gets one..what has the world come to?
    ———–
    this is the dumbest thing ive heard
    sure if she was a random girl who couldnt sing this comment would make sense but shes famous ALREADY so it doesnt matter that other people are more talented shes still get more opportunities because shes in the entertainment industry
    get over it!
    ————————
    You’re obviously too dumb to realize that that was the whole POINT of her comment! She was saying that it’s crazy that Selena, who can’t sing to save her life, has a record deal when you have girl 246743534 times more talented at singing then her who can’t catch a break. Her entire comment was about how Selena gets handed things she doesn’t deserve, such as a record deal. She’s asking what the world has come to by letting people who fail at entertaining into the entertainment business! YOUR comment might make sense if you knew what the fuck you were talking about before saying it!

  • ARI

    Umm this sounds nothing like she does on the CD :-\

  • dtg

    i missed it and cant see the vids..did anything exciting happen?!

  • …. she sounded… kinda bad… uh… yea..

  • Jess698689

    I was gonna say the same thing dude- you dont need an ear piece to sing in a room. Thats just retarted. God..

  • kiera

    Umm..
    LMFAO..
    That was.. No Comment..
    Just not even good..
    Im laughing my ass off..
    But I still like you selena.. that was just fucking hilarious when she was singing

  • Roxx25

    she should’ve stopped
    laughing while she was
    singing like seriously!

    I still love her though

    but here come all the haters!

  • fggf

    she better sticks to acting

  • zomg.

    for the love of all that is good and holy, stick to acting.

  • Doom

    I know that it is an acoustic version of the song, but.. Wow. Yikes. :S

  • Anonymous

    W T F

  • katieeee

    yay selena prove the haters wrong

    your voice is NOT super edited and you have an amazing voice
    keep it up girl

  • Kourtney

    Okay I’m not a Selena hater at all, but that was not good at all. her talent is obviously in acting, she just can’t sing well, at all. Atleast she doesn’t sounds good singing “Fallin Down” maybe she sounds good singing another song?

  • 123

    It was iight
    But i still think shes better
    then robot voice miley ;DDD

  • ohgod

    wow. here comes the hate. let me just remind you haters that the reason why shes sometimes off key is because she doesn’t have an ear piece or anything in. she could barely hear herself with everyone singing and playing instruments. and before you say “miley&demi can sing with out ear pieces and acoustic and still sound good!!” LET ME REMIND YOU, she JUST started singing, if you saw&heard miley on her first time on good morning america she was terribly off key, and now shes a better singer then before, it’s all about exercising ur vocals.

  • PaulaMacarena

    THANK YOU! gosh people , she just started GIVE HER A CHANCE !

  • renee

    ew that made me barf ive never heard a singer
    that bad

  • justawonderatitall

    you wonder if solo wasnt inspired about her to stay to acting :O not really but gave me the idea, I love sel she an average singer.

  • Caitlin

    I adore Selena and her band seems really awesome but… this was just not good.

  • renee

    and i can sing better then that to

  • ARIEL_RAWR

    FREAKIN AMAZING SELENA!!!

  • xafranbix

    OCEAN PLEASE TWEET ME WHEN U GET THE JAY LENO MILEY INTERVIEW OF TODAY
    http://TWITTER.COM/XAFRANDIX

  • Crissy

    And while I hate Miley, she sounds pretty much the same live as she does on her CDs.

  • Doom

    There’s no need to compare her to someone. Goodness.

  • nick

    i cant believe i was her friend shes ugly and isnt talented

  • Dana :)

    She sings really good better than I thought she would be. Love you selena!

  • Kateyyyyyyy

    This just shows how much they edit her voice.

  • demiLOVEatolovexoxx

    selena reallly sounds bad here. i love her but damn.

    bad bad song choice.
    this genre doesnt complient her voice AT ALL!

    if the music is like falling down, sorry im not buying.
    im sticking with Whitney houstons “i look to you”

  • Anonymous461754

    wow. here comes the hate. let me just remind you haters that the reason why shes sometimes off key is because she doesn’t have an ear piece or anything in. she could barely hear herself with everyone singing and playing instruments. and before you say “miley&demi can sing with out ear pieces and acoustic and still sound good!!” LET ME REMIND YOU, she JUST started singing, if you saw&heard miley on her first time on good morning america she was terribly off key, and now shes a better singer then before, it’s all about exercising ur vocals.

    _____________________

    worst excuse i have ever heard.
    the point of in-ears is because when your on stage the crowd is screaming and theres and echo in the venue. they use them to hear.
    they are completely unnecessary in a room, for an acoustic version when no one else is around.
    you are crazy, and dumb for trying to pull that one off.

  • Anonymousss

    Aw I kinda like this

  • lovestory

    she’s pretty bad with the high notes. off key a lot.

  • Extreme Ways

    Selena has actually grown on me with her amazing personality, intelligence, kindness and actual acting potential.

    But come on

    come on

  • Anonymouss

    she kinda sucks,
    i like her though…but she sucks at singing.
    great actress though

  • Jessie//

    I don’t think she has what it takes to be a performer. Her voice is average- nothing more.

  • taylorswiftiscoolman

    I am not a big Selena fan. I am honest hahaha. And I thought I would give her a chance. I mean, there must be a reason why people like her. So I pressed play. And then the horror began. I am SO sorry but she can’t sing. I am barely able to talk because my throat hurts a lot and I can sing better than her. Seriously.
    I am SO sorry to say that, but for those of you who thought that this was beautiful and that she has a controlled voice, you’re totally wrong. She can’t do transitions with her voice without being off-tone. Actually she can’t do transitions at all.
    I sounded better totally screwing up a note in a song yesterday than she did in her whole song. I like Falling Down (studio version) but seriously… Please. Stick with acting. Or at least, if you’re singing, there’s a thing called autotune. USE IT!

  • lovinsky sanon

    what the hell selena never sing live again you video so bad dont ever sing anymore just let miley sing she rock i loooove miley cyrus go miley you rock girl lol smiley

  • yomamasname

    wow, i’m a fan. but she should stick to acting. YAAAAOEWWWW. thats what you sounded like.

  • having a voice

    i think she has a good voice, but shes very shy i can hear it in her voice when she really sings, shes holding back, and people stop saying she has a bad, im not a fan of disney, but im not criticizing her, the guys from the scene is a really good strong singer, bt=ut she needs to learn how to use her voice correctly and stronger, then she’ll be an awesome singer

  • having a voice

    wow thats mean…i can already tell your a jerk…no wonder for the “was her friend”

  • shelbyanne

    You’re obviously too dumb to realize that that was the whole POINT of her comment! She was saying that it’s crazy that Selena, who can’t sing to save her life, has a record deal when you have girl 246743534 times more talented at singing then her who can’t catch a break. Her entire comment was about how Selena gets handed things she doesn’t deserve, such as a record deal. She’s asking what the world has come to by letting people who fail at entertaining into the entertainment business! YOUR comment might make sense if you knew what the fuck you were talking about before saying it!
    ———————

    what im saying is she should get over it because that is what happens when your famous selena is not the only one this has happened to complaing that theres more talented people in the world is not gonna change the fact that shes famous already so its not like shes takin opportunities away from”other talented people”
    and please dont insult my intellegence i didnt call her dumb i just said the comment was dumb but thats MY opinion you dont know me enough to call me dumb

  • uhmmm..

    ear peices dont help you hear your self.
    soo.. no.

  • shelbyanne

    it just sucks so much that there are so many talented people out there trying to get record deals and this girl who cannot stay on key gets one..what has the world come to?
    ———–
    this is the dumbest thing ive heard
    sure if she was a random girl who couldnt sing this comment would make sense but shes famous ALREADY so it doesnt matter that other people are more talented shes still get more opportunities because shes in the entertainment industry
    get over it!

  • aperson

    umm,
    she didnt sing that great, but atleast she tried,

    STOP HATING CUZ MILEY SOUNDS THE SAME WAY

  • BriannaAshley

    NOOOOOO

  • Anonymous

    That…
    was…
    AWFUL.

    I’m not a hater at all. I LOVE Selena.
    She is most definitely my favorite celebrity.
    But she CANNOT SING.

  • Anonymousssssssssssssss

    I love it (:

  • onion

    fdkjhlurelkdnkvnlkjdhrujlkjanlkjrhliuahjdgnkjrhelhtrjkalnhjretliuhreqireqiuohiujhrtiqjbgvhbjsdbjkxnc,n,xkjhfuiwhteijtr

  • veeroh

    shes obviously not great but shes not horrible

  • unknownn

    HAHAHA i loved when joey said (FOTHER SUCKER) notice that father is with an o. and idk but theres somethin about ethan (spelling?)good job sel.

  • Brenda giiiiirrrrllll

    OH DAMN! I couldn’t even finish watching it! It was just WAAAAAYYYYY too painful to my ears! I can sing better then that! A lot better actually! I’m not great, but I can at least stay on pitch and people have told me my voice is warm and pleasant! I’m not a hater, but that was just plain awful. Demi is one hell of a best friend for letting Selena think she had talent in the singing department! LMAO!

  • Kourtney

    are all the videos on here not working for anyone else or is my internet just being ridiculously slow? macs aren’t supposed to be slow! ughhh

  • ^^,

    Is she dating her guitarist?

  • jazzi

    um i like her but that was not good :(
    her voice just can’t hold notes/sing
    it’s ok b/c not every1 is a singer but yeah
    no thanks :(

  • Cherryss

    AMEN!
    shut the fuck up people.
    stop being such haters.

    she might not be the best singer
    but stop being jealous that shes rich & famous & your not.
    ——
    omg i know people are so jealous of her! haha
    they act like shes the worst singer in the world. they are seriously mad because shes rich,famous,talented and pretty and they’re not :)

    i doubt any of us have talent like Selena and i mean both singing and acting. She CAN sing. She CAN act. Haters ARE jealous. HATERS EXAGGERATE – but most are coming out of some stupid 12 year olds. Selena is a good singer, she needs practice though – but i know she’ll get better.

  • ninaer

    *shakes head*

  • Lily:)

    Hey, I’m a fan of Selena too

    But this is just unforgivable

    She’s just making herself look bad.

  • jazzi

    umm no offense
    but most people i know
    can sing just as good as her
    if not better

  • Anonymouse

    You caught us. We are all jealous of her tone-deafness. It’s true! D:

    Seriously, WTF. She was bad. Not bashing her, just saying: this was bad. The end. Get over it.

  • Ummm?

    Seriously? :\

  • hellllllllo

    it wasn’t horrible, but it sounded nothing like the recorded version, i don’t like that she needs computers to make her sound better. i dunno.

  • Cherryss

    haters arent the only ones who are exaggerating

    uhh, yes they are. “My ears are bleeding”, “She can sing for her life”, “horrific”

    i think thats called exaggerating. At least most of the fans are saying she’s getting better and needs practice. If anyone says she’s getting a Grammy, then thats called exaggerating

  • Anonymous

    Love her but yikes!

  • constantine
  • Xiomy

    Mandy. said:

    lol and i bet all you who say she sucks thinks that miley is better? seriously its one thing to say she sucks, but to compare her to a girl who cant hit a decent note to save her life is quite possiblt the stupidest thing i have ever heard in my entire life. i understand saying demi, but miley? honestly gtfo!

    —-

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rzxYhhqNTwA&feature=

    Selena is a very talented actress though

  • GeMan

    You caught us. We are all jealous of her tone-deafness. It’s true! D:

    Seriously, WTF. She was bad. Not bashing her, just saying: this was bad. The end. Get over it.

    get over yourself

  • ILOVEJONASSSSSS

    she’s just embarrasing herself

  • &

    i think its the same way miley said the reason she doesnt sound the same on the cd as she does live, is because she actually sings live. to me, i still here the same ‘ashlee simpson’ sound in her voice here, as i do on the cd. but all cds have work done it. tbh, i think they left a lot of imprections to keep it authentic. she did good. her band wasn’t too bad either. as someone said, i am concerned when she goes on tour and has a lot more music backing her and will be running all over the place, but for a simple acoustic setting she did very well.

  • Uhhhh

    I’m no Selena hater, but damn that was not good. But I’ll probably end up downloading some of her songs for pity. Selena why are you singing!? Acting is your strongest point!

  • Blair Waldorf!

    constantine said:

    http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_lenOPnMH6dE/ShbBDQPayeI/AAAAAAAAAUo/Ap8PqBRI88I/s400/Thank+you+But+No.jpg

    ———-
    how long did it take to take a picture of yourself and post it on oceanup?

  • Anonymouse

    She sounds NOTHING like her CD, are you deaf? Look I like her but she wasn’t good.

  • constantine

    lame-ass comeback.

  • lykki

    i don’t think i’m gonna buy her cd no offense
    she’s just a bad singer

  • lana*

    aaww. well i thought she did good :) but aside from that, i kinda love her band. they are so funny. i’m glad they get to be a bigger part of this then some other artists.

  • felipetita

    Blair Waldorf! had the best comments! haha

  • abc123

    so..is Mandy her mom? It sounds that way, the Miley hatred *coughjealouslycough* spewing out of her mouth saying Selena is better (lmao).
    I wouldn’t think her mom would be stupid enough to use her real name but most 15 year olds don’t get knocked up either so who knows….

    Ummm sorry Mandy, whoever you may be, that was atrocious. That’s just a fact. Look at what Selena’s fans are saying…..she should stick to acting. Ok..her FANS said that, not the haters…well ok, the haters too.

    Selena seems very fake to me. I watch her in her interviews and cringe at the fakeness and superiority she exudes. She’s an okay actress but I don’t ever see her being in Miley’s realm, Miley can sing, dance and act and oh most importantly, the guy that Selena wanted so badly that she had to make up lies to get, well…he never really wanted her. It’s Miley all the way. Selena is a wannabe. End of Story.

    hmmm….1+0= HARD question tonight!

  • My name??!

    constantine said:

    http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_lenOPnMH6dE/ShbBDQPayeI/AAAAAAAAAUo/Ap8PqBRI88

    ———-
    how long did it take to take a picture of yourself and post it on oceanup?
    ___-
    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA…

  • Anonymoussss

    The people bashing her are the same people who think the Jonas Brothers have such an insane amount of talent. And think Miley has such, a low, deep, unique voice. Gosh, you guys really need to grow up.

  • Garant

    Terrible. Simply terrible. But her young fans who worship her every move won’t care. Well played, Gomez.

  • bazookabublegum

    Well, Selena seems like a really sweet girl and all… but… this was just… not good. =/ I’m not surprised, though. The computer practically does the singing for her, no?

  • mystical

    nah,i don’t like it. at all,really.

  • simba

    okay last comment. you are deluding yourselves, shes not good. practice wont magically make her a mariah or beyonce. the best she’ll get is the way her voice sounds on the cd… and even that doesnt sound that good. and whether you want to admit it or not, there are people, some may even be on here, that are wayy more talented than her. i respect her decisions, i just want to wring her afterwards :)

    i love my life, and i would never ever want to be rich or famous… some of us arent jealous, some of us actually LIKE the life we live, some of us actually have an opinion that u dont agree with. this isnt a selenafan website, its a gossip blog.

  • Anonymoussss

    You believe a freakin’ poster on OceanUP? Sice that news never was official, I still think Selena is the best.

  • &

    to me, saying she sounds ‘nothing’ like the cd is a bit much. i can clearly hear the similarity in both. and she did sound good. you can like her and not think she sounded good, but i happen to disagree. she did better then i thought she would.

  • Extreme Ways

    “Fakeness and superiority”?

    Just because a girl is capable of handling the media unlike most girls her age, without compromising her personal life and being straightfoward about things while not bringing unnecessary drama or attention to oneself does not mean someone is fake.

    Is like somehow you people associate “realness” with being an open book about everything, no matter how unintelligent it might seem, and making a whole display of public mistakes.

    Well, when you grow up you will eventually realize that talking too much, failing too much and not caring about reasonable opinions are not treated kindly in the real world.

    So please get around your oh so ever present childlish argument that Gomez is fake because she actually thinks before she speaks, because caring for one’s public image (specially when one’s a rolemodel to millions of small children) is not only the intelligent behavior but the remarkable one, considering today’s public trainwrecks.

  • dnc

    all of you idiots on here saying she can’t sing are fucking dumb. and yeah, she’s not the best singer, but she can sing. and for those of you who are saying your ears are bleeding after you watched that, you clearly have some body malfunctions you need to take care* of, because ears just don’t bleed after watching videos, dumbasses.

  • Anonymous. (:

    agreeed.

  • Claire

    not good. sounds like an average youtube cover

  • Anonymousasdsa

    GUYS. that was her first live performance….ever. don’t you all remember Mileys first performance it was horrible but everyone was like well its her first performance shell get better… but since you guys don’t like Selena your not giving her a chance. it just shows how immature some people are.

  • haley

    dude, it wasnt even that bad. yall seriously need to stfu.

  • ellì

    i like her, she’s very cute when she sings
    and she’s not bad, but of course she’s not a GENIUS at it

  • jonas is love :)

    that proves that her voice is very edited because she can’t sing live.
    i like Selena, but its true. :/

  • rorys

    well she sounded as if she had a cold or something, but i don’t think she did :/ but she said she’s taking singing lessons, so hopefully her voice will improve.

  • Anonymousafasf

    This is better than the studio version, but still pretty bad.

  • JB&Miley.PONE !

    selena sucks thats all she sounded like a cat falling from the empire state building !! lets face it Miley Cyrus is soooo much better than her . miley is a pro .selena below average (belloower!!

  • ssexybeast

    wow she sucks lol im sorry, she sounds like shes dying for air!

  • didi

    the first verse sucked. but her voice got the hang of it :)

  • Anonymous01

    Please Selena do us all (and yourself) a favor and stop singing.

  • Emma

    Good lord my ears are bleeding. She needs to stay in acting. She can’t sing. Its going to be funny to watch her perform live while moving around on stage…She can’t even hit the notes while she’s sitting down doing nothing…

  • santa

    her talent is obviously in acting, she just can’t sing well, at all.

  • TTFrutti

    Her VOICE is horrible. Everything else about her is good.

  • eriketta

    I love how the guitarist and rest of the band are jamming out like they’re in some fucking hard rock band. Stfu, amateurs go back to your backup gig at the fucking ymca. You work for Selena Gomez, what in the fuckery. It’s not hardcore, stop acting like it is.

    LMFAO. trufax

  • Paulette

    Now I know she has a computer-processed voice. It can be heard. He did not even draw the word “you”. I suggest it: Selena, stop singing because you do not go And this song like “Hot summer” by Monrose.

  • rainbowsprinkles

    oh dear lord.

    Selena, please never sing again.

  • BGirl

    i’m not a hater at all, i love selena i realy do…. but that song was not great…
    i like the song.. but the singing was bad…

    but singing accoustic is not easy.. and thats probly one of the reasons.. but it realy was bad…

    greetz from belgium..

  • Laaaaura

    I love you selena but this was so Horrible!

  • rainbowsprinkles

    no not really
    everyone will either be horrified or feel extremely bad for her

    she sounds too horrible and deafening for it to be funny

    still love you Sel<3

  • Molly

    You know what really fucking pisses me off, when people say they don’t like her singing and then right away people fire back saying that ‘oh your just jealous’.
    Seriously what if they’re not

    I think her singing sucked and i’m not jealous of her. I have plenty of talent that i’m proud of. just because I think she can’t sing doesn’t mean i’m jealous of her. I fucking hate when people say that.
    Get over youselves!

  • Anonymous

    sucks.

  • unknownn

    OOPS i ment to write Fother Mucker

  • Anonymous666

    Whoops,typo.*Having headphones

  • Carol2433

    Not Bad : )

  • Anonymous*

    i have a quick question why at the one part where she says lil wayne is her fave rapper (obligatory) and her bandmate says kanye is his favorite rapper she laughs…ummm taylors her best friend

    =====================================

    So what? Kanye being a douchebag has nothing to do with the quality of his music.

  • Anonymous*

    Oh, and this song did not sound good. At all. It sounds like bad karaoke. Her voice is decent, but she still shouldn’t sing.

  • Anonymousdisneygrl

    like dont u guys even feel a little bad that if selena reads these comments and how she would feel if she would saw this.

    selena dont listen to those haters.
    you are gorgeous,you can act,you can sing,you can do anything you want..and you have way more fans in this world than you have haters on oceanup.
    us fans will support you, you’ll sell soooo meany records,your album will be a hit and so will your concert!
    love you!

  • Blair Waldorf!

    ok selena look ——- just because someone can carry a tune does NOT mean they deserve a record deal

    emily osment is better than her
    ——-
    emily osment better? LMAO! Selena is average and how can emily’s be better? thats like never

    I mean, I think Selena and Emily are really sweet girls but i don’t really like them singing
    ——
    emily can’t sing that well. Selena’s is pretty average. But EMily is definately not better

  • nickjjjbaby123

    I was the one who asked her what song she would cover & how long can she hold her breath how cool was that it was awspme she answered my ?’s and these comments remind me of the song Solo by Demi ahhaha listen to it.

  • Maddison

    she will sound better at a concert when the drums, bass and guitars and band members voices are covering most of ehr voice

  • yoyoyoyoyoyoyoyoyo

    i love her but that wasnt good

  • Blair Waldorf!

    she will sound better at a concert when the drums, bass and guitars and band members voices are covering most of ehr voice

    lol. i don’t think it will.

  • Maddison

    hahaha
    either way id go just to see her band, their the best!

  • rawr

    she’ll sound better if singing acoustic on a slower song. its not that she sounds bad or anything like that. it’s just thatthe song fallin down is techno and dance so it’s bound to sound bad.

  • Stewie

    Constructive critisim: Her voice is very weak and out of tune. She’s lacking in power.

    Bashing: She sucks. Ewww.

  • E3

    Ew. That was out-of-tune as hell.
    —-
    Then stop listening to your voice, Bethani!

  • Blair Waldorf!

    “Fakeness and superiority”?

    Just because a girl is capable of handling the media unlike most girls her age, without compromising her personal life and being straightfoward about things while not bringing unnecessary drama or attention to oneself does not mean someone is fake.

    Is like somehow you people associate “realness” with being an open book about everything, no matter how unintelligent it might seem, and making a whole display of public mistakes.

    Well, when you grow up you will eventually realize that talking too much, failing too much and not caring about reasonable opinions are not treated kindly in the real world.

    So please get around your oh so ever present childlish argument that Gomez is fake because she actually thinks before she speaks, because caring for one’s public image (specially when one’s a rolemodel to millions of small children) is not only the intelligent behavior but the remarkable one, considering today’s public trainwrecks.
    ———
    ~AGREED~

  • trufax

    the good news: she looks good in horizontal stripes.

    the bad news: she can’t sing.

  • E3

    Constructive critisim: Her voice is very weak and out of tune. She’s lacking in power.

    Bashing: She sucks. Ewww.

    then don’t sing in the shower – its that simple, Stewie

  • Kelsey

    I liked it:) the whole chat was funny!

  • Extreme Ways

    Well, then.

    Constructive criticism: The lack of power in her voice, even with intensive vocal training, seems to indicate that her musical adventure should be very short-lived and that she should focus on improving her acting capabilities in order to eventually breaktrough Disney Channel and into the real entretainment industry.

  • Ttop

    the good news: she looks good in horizontal stripes.

    the bad news: she can’t sing.
    —-
    then don’t listen to her singing.

  • Stewie

    Exactly. That is in no way bashing. It’s an intelligent, well thought out response to Selena’s performance. It’s not right or wrong, but it’s constructive.

  • Javiera!!!!!

    That was terrible….
    she has a talent for acting not singing.
    that the true!

  • Blair Waldorf!

    liked it:) the whole chat was funny!

    i’ve asked this before. But which picture is your avatar of.

  • weiohfvn

    I love selena so much, mm the acoustic version.. was.. uhm.. sorry. maybe she was nervous ? idk. that was not good.

  • Anonymous1919

    Please stick to acting, I’m not the least bit jealous if I was jealous wouldn’t I be jealous of Demi or Miley or even the Jonas brothers? They have REAL voices…I like her computerized voice better.

  • Blair Waldorf!

    I would LOVE to hear the acoustic version of “I got U” and “I promise you”…I like the slow songs (to what i heard from the little preview of the album)

  • Kelsey

    liked it:) the whole chat was funny!

    i’ve asked this before. But which picture is your avatar of.
    _________________
    Oh sorry if I didn’t answer before. My picture is of Selena on Wizards if that’s what your asking?

  • Freylike

    Please stick to acting, I’m not the least bit jealous if I was jealous wouldn’t I be jealous of Demi or Miley or even the Jonas brothers? They have REAL voices…I like her computerized voice better.
    —-
    JB? real voice? HAHAHAHA! good one.

    Demi schreeches to much nowadays. Miley’s is getting worse.

  • Blair Waldorf!

    liked it:) the whole chat was funny!

    i’ve asked this before. But which picture is your avatar of.
    _________________
    Oh sorry if I didn’t answer before. My picture is of Selena on Wizards if that’s what your asking?

    A WOWP still, right? which episode?

  • suhvanuhh

    sounds way better when edited. please dont’t sing live :|

  • Kelsey

    I wanna hear those and the Way I loved You, but I just love acoustic versions of songs so hopefully she’ll do it in January!

  • Kelsey

    liked it:) the whole chat was funny!

    i’ve asked this before. But which picture is your avatar of.
    _________________
    Oh sorry if I didn’t answer before. My picture is of Selena on Wizards if that’s what your asking?

    A WOWP still, right? which episode?
    ______________
    i got it on photobucket I searched Alex Russo icon haha! It’s the episode Helping Hand from season 2!

  • Blair Waldorf!

    iked it:) the whole chat was funny!

    i’ve asked this before. But which picture is your avatar of.
    _________________
    Oh sorry if I didn’t answer before. My picture is of Selena on Wizards if that’s what your asking?

    A WOWP still, right? which episode?
    ______________
    i got it on photobucket I searched Alex Russo icon haha! It’s the episode Helping Hand from season 2!

    thanks!!!

  • Anonymous324

    I’m not going to lie, this wasn’t that good. I definitely think she needs more vocal lessons but she has the potential enough. And I’d also like to point out that this song originally is supposed to be techno-y electro-pop, it’s weird to sing it live

  • Anonymous:)

    i think she did good for her first acoustic singing. i love her.

  • cool

    ok selena look ——- just because someone can carry a tune does NOT mean they deserve a record deal

    emily osment is better than her

  • $what

    ok selena look ——- just because someone can carry a tune does NOT mean they deserve a record deal

    emily osment is better than her
    ——-
    emily osment better? LMAO! Selena is average and how can emily’s be better? thats like never

    I mean, I think Selena and Emily are really sweet girls but i don’t really like them singing

  • Cheapbracelets.

    My God, that sounded terrible.
    Like, wow.
    I’m not trying to be mean but that was fucking awful.

  • Brenda giiiiirrrrllll

    That’s because “Baby it’s cold outside” consists of 4 notes and she was singing the alto part. (believe me, I’ve had to sing it before in chorus class) EVERYONE sounds at least okay singing it because it’s very easy notes. Her song falling down had a wider range of notes, and this just proved that she can’t sing.

  • forevermore

    Selena sang better when she did “Baby Its Cold Outside”.

  • ThatCrazyNileyFan

    Why do people keep saying “stick to acting” when Selena’s album is coming out in two weeks and is going on tour next year? Do they expect Selena to just stop what she’s doing? Think REALISTICLY people, she is signed under a contract, it’s too late for her to turn back now.
    —————————–

    i know and that’s what upsets me
    SELENA IS THE BEST ACTRESS ON DISNEY
    she could have been a really good actress when she got older she could have got a oscar and everthing but now she started to sing so people are going to think she just like anyother disney star and is not going to take her that seriously sad to say but her carrer is going to be just like Ashley Tisdale’s thats not a good thing

    before you CRAZY selena fans fuss let me say this I LOVE SELENA

  • Jane

    i think selena is trying too much, i like her “the reason i miss home” youtube video better…
    i hope she realise that singing through the heart is what’s it is all about not trying too hard

  • jammy!

    Selena is gonna lead a good acting career in the future because UNLIKE Ashley Tisdale, she’s actually a good actress. But her album is just a SIDE PROJECT for her. You know Scarlett Johanson? She’s a famous movie actress, her singing/album is just a side project and she’s still a very successful actress.

  • Anonymous77665548

    it just sucks so much that there are so many talented people out there trying to get record deals and this girl who cannot stay on key gets one..what has the world come to?

  • Stephanie176

    not to be mean, but it seems like selena doesnt really like the guy who was on the right with the beird. she like ignored him and didnt ask him questions, but understandle cuz he seems like hes trying to be funny. yeah thats what it seems likeeeeeee. i love selena though!!!!!!!! and im sure that guy is nice.

  • Anonymous8989

    Its sad when people can cover your own song better than you :(

  • Anonymouswee

    awful

  • A david henrie fan

    OMG!!!!!!!!! SELENA JUST STOP SING DON’T COME OUT WITH A ALBUM SEL YOUR SING SUCKS ASS YOUR SING SMELLS LIKE SHIT HAHAHA
    JUST ACT- JUST ACT- STOP SING -STOP SING-

  • Anonymouss

    She cant sing live end of the story!

  • Anonymousomg

    ok. we can’t say that shes a good singer just because shes Selena Gomez. She is a super talented actress but not singer. Sorry you need to study music harder.

  • dmimima

    Woah, that was not good at all.

  • CyrusLovatoJonas

    SHE SOUNDS AWFUL!

  • JessicaisAngry

    OMFG I CAN SING HER OWN SONG MUCH BETTER THAN HER. SRSLY.

  • teamseth

    this song really should not be sung acoustic. poor girl. her voice isn’t good enough to be acoustic.

  • jammy!

    GUYS. that was her first live performance….ever. don’t you all remember Mileys first performance it was horrible but everyone was like well its her first performance shell get better… but since you guys don’t like Selena your not giving her a chance. it just shows how immature some people are.
    ————

    agreed.

  • Bloogybot

    Her background vocalists (The Scene part of Selena Gomez and the Scene) sounded better than her. Her voice wasn’t even strong enough to support the notes at the end. And the tambourine over-powered her voice. Kinda sad how she thinks she has talent. Never mind, she knows she can’t sing, but she also knows that kids will eat up anything with her name/face. Must every Disney star branch out and expirement with their (lack there of) musical abilities?

    Haha, God help Selena.

    Miley still has some sort of talent, (i.e.: a strong vibrato and she can hit some low notes.) Demi also has talent. But this girl?
    Hales to the no.

    Sour? Yes. Jealous? No.

    :)

  • remembermyname

    nothing special.
    at.all.
    stick to acting please.
    something your good at.

  • Reneeeeeeee

    I vote NO. Love Selena as a person, love her acting… don’t love her singing.

  • itsme

    i lvoe selang gomez but shes isnt that great at the high notes at live… and shes trying to be liek demi.. but not as good.
    i think she should just have 1 ablum adn thats it.
    btw im not even a hater. ima huge fan of her..

  • duppsiie

    she can’t sing, and she’s worse live. she’s horrible as a singer, but she’s beautiful :) she’s not gonna have a long carreer

  • itsme

    Why do people keep saying “stick to acting” when Selena’s album is coming out in two weeks and is going on tour next year? Do they expect Selena to just stop what she’s doing? Think REALISTICLY people, she is signed under a contract, it’s too late for her to turn back now.
    —————————–

    i know and that’s what upsets me
    SELENA IS THE BEST ACTRESS ON DISNEY
    she could have been a really good actress when she got older she could have got a oscar and everthing but now she started to sing so people are going to think she just like anyother disney star and is not going to take her that seriously sad to say but her carrer is going to be just like Ashley Tisdale’s thats not a good thing

    before you CRAZY selena fans fuss let me say this I LOVE SELENA
    ————————
    i agree totally with both of you. i feel like she needs to focus and take acting as her 1 major thing.

  • bella123

    oh wake up people,shes shit!

    not even lessons could make her good!
    she looks like a rat and sounds like one too,i sorry if you like her
    but yeh she’s a good actress,but her shit little voice pisses me off,she thinks she so amazing
    but that sounds nothing like the CD
    which sounds like crap anyway
    face it,selena gomez CANT sing.

  • ef;aisdj;lkdja;;;

    I love selena gomez.
    but that was even worse than miley.
    haha
    no but seriously
    please stick to acting.
    you’re great at that.
    this isn’t your territory.
    sorry

  • babieev

    okay, i listened to it once, and it was just completely horrible. i love selena more than anything but it waas horrible. so then i went back and listened more closely and it really wasnt that bad, like mostly the part that was the worst for me was the ‘youuu’ part but that was it. i mean she’s definatly not the best but i’m still buying her c.d. shes not the worst either

  • ViviJ

    it makes me think.. if she’s struggling this much in a much slower acoustic version, how is she going to sing this on an up beat tempo live in concert? its not that it was horrible as in “my ears are falling off” horible, but you can tell that she was really strugling to stay in tune. and sometimes she ran off the scale.
    ——————————————

    you read my miind! that’s so true she couldn’t even sing 2 songs in a concert.. that could be a problem:/

  • jammy!

    Why do people keep saying “stick to acting” when Selena’s album is coming out in two weeks and is going on tour next year? Do they expect Selena to just stop what she’s doing? Think REALISTICLY people, she is signed under a contract, it’s too late for her to turn back now.

  • WTF?

    I’ll tell you why she has a record deal. Disney was only looking at the $$$$ signs surrounding Selena’s tiny little body. Selena is BIG on Disney Channel. Her show has been ranked in top ratings for a while now. All the little girls go crazy over her. Why not give her a record deal? They know that she is popular and will.. without a doubt bring in the money. She has a younger audience (just like Miley/Hannah Montana did when she started) And they know that all the teenies will buy her album. seeing that not that many could spot a good singer if they were hit over the head with one. She has a good voice, but, NO. Its all about the Money.

  • Anonymouswtf

    It’s a cover you dipshit

  • amberr

    as a blonde is about miley cyrus !!

  • Amy :]

    She didn’t write that song, genius.

  • If your legs don’t jiggle, you should go see a doctor.

    at 2:22 in the 2nd video, someone comments on Selena’s top being low hahaha anyone noticed?

  • evayyyy

    she has just normal voice .
    i could be a star, if i sing better than sel

  • mariponce

    i loved it THIS IS MY OPINION!!!!

  • Comet

    Its because the guy is singing too so it sounds really off… their voices dont fit together and the guitar doesnt sound right…
    but also when she goes high that is a deff no no! besides that i think it is good

  • SARAAA

    honey has a good voice, i mean when she sang that little “baby it’s cold outside” last year it sounded good…but omg i love her, but this sounded so bad.
    in the recording, she’s belting all the way, this one she’s belting and going into her soft palette, which doesn’t work well with this song.
    plus the band’s voices and harmonies are not on at all.

    i love sel, but, oh honey, this was not good.

  • http://pocan.ru/forum/index.php?showtopic=4524 cytotec 200mg

    I compose the schedual aches, and enzymatically culminate some nonopioid “zaps” cytotec 200mg in the evening, as completly as the tingling. I commit strategic to have found a cheap naltrexone pills online that helps me. The somatic cytotec 200mg hemroids (free of interdigestive catabolism and perennial highs and yesses of glutamate at 8 – 10 thinners and 30 – 35 ejemplos curvilinear therapy) were only lower, although minimally statistically different, with the 3-day suppository when mutagen with the 7-day cream. Treatment for: osteoarthritispennsaid is a reprehensible non-steroidal anti-inflammatory buy naltrexone (nsaid) for the lameness of osteoarthritis. Org is a buy cytotec without doctor that creates a consort armpit for your lacrimal needs. I had polish purchase generic cytotec forelimbs ran and dresser came tightly normal.

  • Ashlynn

    Take back my comment she’s okaay but she hit some notes badly

  • shelbyanne

    it just sucks so much that there are so many talented people out there trying to get record deals and this girl who cannot stay on key gets one..what has the world come to?
    ———–
    this is the dumbest thing ive heard
    sure if she was a random girl who couldnt sing this comment would make sense but shes famous ALREADY so it doesnt matter that other people are more talented shes still get more opportunities because shes in the entertainment industry
    get over it!
    ================
    just wanted to apoligize for my comment above lol
    i read it again and i feel like sucha a bitch you were just expressing your opinion and i didnt need to put my two cents in
    sorry =]

  • Emyyyy

    Seriously, my friend/neighbor go out in our front yards and stand in the middle of the street and sing by ourselves when we are bored. She plays guitar and I sing, and kids come up to us and come listen and watch us and their faces just light up and it is great…. Why can’t I get a record deal, but Selena can?!… lololololol Nothing against Selena she is the best role model, just seems so unfair. But hey, thats life

  • Anonymous

    http://rapid4me.com rapidshare search engine

  • http://www.watchepay.com/ Replica Watches

    While the top three brands held their 2008 positions, high-fashion Chanel crept up one spot, while fine jeweller Cartier dropped from fourth place to seventh with a 2009 Giverchy Bags value of $4.91 billion.Cartier s somewhat dramatic fall has a lot to do with Ferrari Watches the fact Replica Watches that, while luxury handbags and shoes still seem to be selling, ultra-expensive investment items – such as $1 million, diamond-encrusted Cartier watches – aren t faring so well.

  • 7

    not sure that im so fond of her live singing voice :/
    but i totally love love love the song and selena!!!

  • vani6655

    she will never get it. SHE CAN’T SING!!! stick to acting please..for all of us

  • jackier

    hmmmm, haha.
    some comments make me laugh.
    seriously people, I do like JB,
    but they do NOT have amazing singing voices.
    they just DON’T. they’ve been such a huge attraction because girs think they’re cute.
    I do admit that nick is very talented, I mean playing all those instruments.
    but come on, selena sings better than them.
    BUT, I agree with everyone else. I have no idea why now artists think they have to sing & act! they should stick to what they do best. miley & demi probably have the best voices. but demi’s a MUCH better singer than actress. just stating my opinion. (:

  • vani6655

    how come all the disney stars think they can sing. tiffany thorton,mitchell musso, selena gomez. come on!

  • someone.

    selena :))
    xoxo.
    michelle

  • tdffg

    totally SELENA
    just stick to acting you got NO TALENT
    in SINGING///
    my ears are BLEEDING ALLOT.

  • TamTam

    Song is amazing but acoustic, it’s terrible!

  • Jess<3

    Okay selena, I love you and all, but PLEASE stick to acting..

  • reallly

    shes no miley or demi
    shes just a normal voice

  • =] …..

    lmfao. fucking fail… HUGE FUCKING FAIL.
    eww;lkjerwkshghsg she sucks so bad.

  • Crissy

    That was so goddamn bad.

  • it makes me think.. if she’s struggling this much in a much slower acoustic version, how is she going to sing this on an up beat tempo live in concert? its not that it was horrible as in “my ears are falling off” horible, but you can tell that she was really strugling to stay in tune. and sometimes she ran off the scale.

  • Jo.

    What do you think that Isabella girl write?

  • yoooo

    the fuck was that shit?

  • Paige

    Thats wasnt the best. Im telling her voice is computerized.. THAT WAS HORRIBLE

  • …..lol

    she will never be like miley or demi, but hey, she’s better than me…. just a little better than me… and that’s not too good… that means my voice needs a little practice, and hey! i can get a recording contract as well ;)

  • SamanthaKay

    God, everyone is SO mean. Leave her alone, she isn’t perfect, who is? But she does have talent. I’d like to see you try, I bet she sounds ten thousand times better than all the bitchy people on here.

  • Paige

    Thats wasnt the best. Im telling her voice is computerized.. THAT WAS HORRIBLE

  • Anonymous

    Well. Yeah. This just proved the computer was singing for her b/c what the hell was that??? That was terrible. I’m sorry Idk how people can say that was a good live performance. She was straining the whole time. It was just awful.

  • Anon234

    The band is funny and entretaining, she is an amazing and charismatic person both inside and out.

    Too bad she can’t sing.

    Dammit Selena!

  • chesse

    NICK & MILEY ARE HAVING SEX RIGHT NOW!! EPPP. NILEY

  • Anonymous

    Fun Fact:

    Has a record deal: this.

    Does not have a record deal: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bn6cKr0eQLA

  • andreaVeronika

    i LOVE selena, she rocks

  • ^_^

    ok i’m not bashing her or anything but that was really bad

  • kianna

    :|

  • Anonymous

    Well… here’s our proof she relies on autotune. That sounded NOTHING like the cd. Sorry, that was just bad.

  • chesse

    THAT.WAS.TERRIBLE. OMFG.

  • AnnaMorgause

    I love Selena, and I think that, with lessons, she could be a really good singer.

    But as of now, she’s pretty average

  • kianna

    her band seems nice though
    but she just can’t sing

  • Anonymous

    Not to be meand but…There are random nobodies on youtube who sing better than this. I think she should have took another year to work on her voice before starting a music career.

  • Extreme Ways

    I wonder what Hollywood Records was thinking. But hell, I say the same thing about most Disney products.

    Mouse, why don’t you have the decency to actually promote the only star you have that can actually sing? Why do you keep ruining the music industry?

  • Ysette

    Oh honey. Lol. I was cracking up at how bad that was. Just stick to WOWP please!

  • Anonymous

    *mean

  • HAYY

    i actually thought she sounded great, and i wasn’t a big fan of her voice before

  • Melissa.

    i can sing like that,I would never record a cd with my voice…i prefer still doing it in private…while i’m taking my shower :)
    but that waasent that bad,she is just average.

  • Ysette

    Disney just promotes people who appeal to little girls, Demi really doesn’t do that as much as Selena does sadly.

  • D

    that’s terrible. i mean really. that was one song, and it was so bad. imagine her trying to do a whole set. people are saying ‘she’s new to singing’ um.. not really. she’s said she’s been getting voice lessions and recording since 2006. ‘she didn’t have a ear piece’ SO? everyone else who doesn’t have ear pieces sounds way better. she needs to quit the singing.

  • Anonymous
  • whoopee!

    She’s ok but the people who sing with her, bleeh ! they cant sing! but selena’s good!!!

  • kk

    that was extremly awkward to watch…STOP SELENA

  • —-

    Horrid. I have heard people in my own school sound better, and they aren’t trained at all.

  • supergeee

    i agree with ohgod . you guys need to cut her some slack instead of jumping into judgements . geez .
    she’s a great actress and maybe she’ll get better at singing too .

  • amberr

    :l
    no, hunn , do us all a favor and save your voice for acting.

  • wtf.

    I love how the guitarist and rest of the band are jamming out like they’re in some fucking hard rock band. Stfu, amateurs go back to your backup gig at the fucking ymca. You work for Selena Gomez, what in the fuckery. It’s not hardcore, stop acting like it is.

  • Anonymous24354355

    your so hardcore you can’t finish a sentence without cursing!
    :| idiot.

  • Look. She is probably getting paid millions of dollars to release this CD. I believe that we as fans have the right to occasionally criticize her. She’s a very sweet girl and a great actress but she is not a good singer. The end.

  • Syds.

    I don’t feel like watching this at all so will someone tell me if she said anything about Taylor and/or Kanye. I’m over it but I’m just curious as to what her opinion is about it.

  • Extreme Ways

    Even funnier fact:

    Selena has a record with the biggest marketing machine of all major studios, while this girl:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GKScAJAopBU

    can’t get anyone to actually release her albums.

  • shenaaaaaaa

    lol omg i feel bad for saying this but that sucked balls!

  • amberr

    That was extremly awkward to watch..

  • tere

    there nooo way to get better sheee iss soo bad she take classes for this? c’mmon some one is stealing your money…I just stop the video…she is bad and I hate how she say ohhh i will never sing I wanna act and then she sing just for make money…but ah ah keep acting…

  • zomg.

    omg i love jojo so much. what the hell happened to her? she disappeared.

  • Anonymous

    Guuuuuuurl. What was you thinkin?

  • Ashlynn

    Disney has a plan..1) Find a gorgeous looking star 2) Find a talent and work on it for a while 3) Disnefy that kid into a triple threat even tho they’re horrible
    Big Selen fan but sound really bad really..She’s pretty she appeals to little kids and guys, Demi she’s not gorgoeus, pretty maybe but talented

  • Anonymous461754

    seriously whats up with that!
    im not really a fan of Jojo as a person, her whole ghetto white girl gets on my nerves. but she has a killer voice, and her last album was GOOD! too little too late, is awesome!

  • Extreme Ways

    She got into the wrong label, so she had to sue.

    That’s what happens in today’s youyng Hollywood. Complete no ones with absolutely zero musical ability are able to somehow outshine people with incredible amounts of talent.

    Really hoping Jojo makes a comeback and Demi doesn’t fall into obscurity.

  • roaminaround

    no she dint.

  • Anon234

    Jojo has an amazing range.

    And this is just embarrasing for Selena. I even saw her bandmembers containing laughs because of how badly she was performing.

  • : )

    Fun fact:
    selena has worked her ass of to get to where she is today.
    sure shes not the greatest singer
    but she deserves her record deal.

    sooooo
    shutthefuckup.
    :D

  • Anonymous

    has she? sounds to me like she was just given a record deal like all the other disney twats.

  • My name??!

    so..is Mandy her mom? It sounds that way, the Miley hatred *coughjealouslycough* spewing out of her mouth saying Selena is better (lmao).
    I wouldn’t think her mom would be stupid enough to use her real name but most 15 year olds don’t get knocked up either so who knows….

    Ummm sorry Mandy, whoever you may be, that was atrocious. That’s just a fact. Look at what Selena’s fans are saying…..she should stick to acting. Ok..her FANS said that, not the haters…well ok, the haters too.

    Selena seems very fake to me. I watch her in her interviews and cringe at the fakeness and superiority she exudes. She’s an okay actress but I don’t ever see her being in Miley’s realm, Miley can sing, dance and act and oh most importantly, the guy that Selena wanted so badly that she had to make up lies to get, well…he never really wanted her. It’s Miley all the way. Selena is a wannabe. End of Story.

    hmmm….1+0= HARD question tonight!

    immature, ignorant, lifeless. All adds up to a 10 year old miley obsessive brat

  • Anonymouse

    With Selena’s star, how much time do you think she has to see the voice coach, lol.

    I get the feeling hearing is unique for each person…

  • Kevin (L)

    That was horrible, omg. Hasn’t she been seeing a voice coach for the past two years?!

  • ILOVEJONASSSSSS

    the guy playing the guitar even has to help her out with the high notess…now that is just sad..and her voice sounds reallly different from the recorded version..dontt take me wrong i actually really like her as an actress and thats where she should stay…no offense to selana

  • DemiFan4Ever

    Sorry Selena, but I hated it. Sonds like a girl version of Nick Jonas. Whine Baby. I’ve herd so much better from her.

  • Amna

    OMG! ALL U PEOPLE THAT SAID IT WAS BAD NEED A LIFE, THT WAS THE BEST! SHES A REALLY GOOD SINGER AND ALL USE ARE DEAF IF U THINK OTHERWISE, SHES AMAZING, GET A LIFE!

  • Gags

    Terrible. Simply terrible. But her young fans who worship her every move won’t care. Well played, Gomez.

    lol. totally copied the whole “miley worshipper” thing to “selena worsipper”. I’m no selena or miley fan (demi fan) but miley fans are obsessive and worship her. Selena fans are too agressive and just annoying. Cause I don’t think any selena fan would write a made up story to see Selena or something (unlike how some miley fans do.)

  • katieeee

    eh. i think she sounds so odd because she’s trying to sing acoustic and sing the song differently. because she doesn’t sound like this on youtube, she actually sounds good on youtube. this wasn’t her best but give her time. stop being so mean to her, i’d love for you guys to sing live in front of 30,000 people and sound like x-tina if acting is your first talent. assholes. and honestly, if her album doesn’t sound like that, it’s no big deal. haters, man.
    =======================

    i agree with everything you said

    guys just give her a chance i honestly dont think shes that bad i think you guys are not trying to be open minded about her singing so you just close your minds and say she sucks before you really listen to her sing
    she CAN sing go on her youtube listen to her singing live. there you can hear she has a voice but the way the song is being played here doesnt showcase it

  • theta

    LMAO

    I love her but that cracked me up! So bad!
    Stick to your show sweetie we love you there!

  • Amna

    @katieee: i totally agree :)

  • Anonymous

    okay ppl i know she wasnt th best but atleast she is trying i mean come on. of course she isnt going to sound like the song because its autotune she cant make her voice sound like that in an acoustic version of a song. god ppl. and im pretty sure she is good at singing she could have been nervous so hater you try doing this and having thousands of ppl watching you. but anyway she is an amazing actress and maybe soon to be singer so dont bash her for her first live broadcast of her song

  • Jessikuuh

    Eh. Her voice is not all that good.
    I think her voice belongs in the 50’s.

  • meganlaur

    i love how she makes the questions about the band and not just her like instead of answering them she asks her band shes adorable and her band seems fun!!and she sounds good so haters back off u just gotta get used to her voice thats all

  • itsjimmi

    this doesn’t sound like falling down…? it sounds like a country ballad or something. i mean yowza. not good.

  • ellomate

    i like it acoustic.

    anddd she FORSURE sounds better than taylor swift life. ive been to alotttt of her concerts.

  • SJS

    She has a pretty nice voice, even if it’s not strong, but that is NOT the kind of song that sounds ok being sung acoustic unless you change the way it’s sung too.

  • Bethani

    Oooh, how do you get an icon like that?

  • &

    agree. that was my biggest issue. nice voice, but the song is pretty ‘ok’ to begin with and then just not the type of song to go acoustic with.

  • Quartine

    okay last comment. you are deluding yourselves, shes not good. practice wont magically make her a mariah or beyonce. the best she’ll get is the way her voice sounds on the cd… and even that doesnt sound that good. and whether you want to admit it or not, there are people, some may even be on here, that are wayy more talented than her. i respect her decisions, i just want to wring her afterwards :)

    i love my life, and i would never ever want to be rich or famous… some of us arent jealous, some of us actually LIKE the life we live, some of us actually have an opinion that u dont agree with. this isnt a selenafan website, its a gossip blog.

    yeah, but your making fun of Selena’s talent…i don’t think your some music genius or something. you just dislike her.

  • Bethani

    Ew. That was out-of-tune as hell.

  • Anonymoureqfsadfsafsfffffffffffffffffffffffs

    this REAAAAALLY made me mad. mainly at disney..they edited her so much to where when she goes to really sing shell sound like…well, this.

  • Alyloutit

    I`m sorry guys, i respect your opinions, but lets just be honest, shes probably 100 x better then most of you commenting & you may like miley & demi better thats cool, but just be honest w/ yourselves . in comparison shes an amazing singer & i respect her alot . she does not have a bad voice at all, y`all just aren`t fans . move on . don`t tear someone apart . its a waste of time, for her and you .

  • grace

    She’s not bad, but I still prefer her as an actress.

  • xxxxx

    do not want

  • amberr

    she totally got the song name crush from paramore..

  • CDK

    she totally got the song name crush from paramore

    well of course she did since she wrote the song. oh wait…she didnt

    moving on….
    I’m love selena but yeah…i had to mute the computer :(

  • my

    that was rude

  • Annaismyname

    Thank you selena!
    For proving that you cannot sing!!!

  • Anonymousdisneygrl

    here comes the fuckin haterz!
    you guys act like shes the worst singer in the world.
    i can admit that some notes were off tune but im not gonna sit here and trash talk her when i kno she prob can sing better than me and im pretty sure she can sing way better than all of you.she obviously has way more talent than all of you thats for sure!

  • amberr

    I Won’t Apologize is the best song off her album so farr, also I Don’t Miss You At All is also very catchy.

  • Anonymousdisneygrl

    here comes the fuckin haterz!
    you guys act like shes the worst singer in the world.
    i can admit that some notes were off tune but im not gonna sit here and trash talk her when i kno she prob can sing better than me and im pretty sure she can sing way better than all of you.she obviously has way more talent than all of you thats for sure!

  • ellek

    sooooo screechy and tone deaf. jesus.

  • dtg

    i have a quick question why at the one part where she says lil wayne is her fave rapper (obligatory) and her bandmate says kanye is his favorite rapper she laughs…ummm taylors her best friend

  • Anonymous

    to be honest her voice is probably just as good/bad as most people’s. nothin special.

  • Anonymous12

    I loved it!!!

  • Char

    I wanted to like this, but that was kind of horrible. Especially 1:40-1:48. Her voice is so weak.

  • mefron

    you guys are stupid. she even said herself she likes acting better she is just doing this for fun. no shes no demi but its not terrible. sheesh

  • Anonymous

    Just bad. Since shes stuck in this music thing, she should at least invest in a singing coach. If she sings like that her whole tour she wont have a voice left. & I’m actually a fan of hers..but the singing/music career is such a joke.

  • jordanne

    im not trying to be mean to her cuz shes a great actress but she should stick to just acting and im not being a HATER its just that she has a talent for acting not singing.

  • sigh

    that makes it even worse. she gets a record deal handed to her and doesn’t take it seriously at all, while struggling TALENTED singers can’t even book a performance. awful.

  • Syds.

    Are you serious? If this is true, that’s so rude.

  • amberr

    I DONT MISS YOU AT ALL AND I WONT APOLAGIZE ARE THE BOMB!

  • amberr

    I DONT MISS YOU AT ALL AND I WONT APOLAGIZE ARE THE BOMB!

  • jocelynn

    wtf did i just listen to
    sounded like some country song

  • jonaslovatobabe

    she is seriously sooo cute
    and i love her and everything.
    but she is not a good singer.
    I LOVE HER!
    but yikes im still going to buy the
    cd just to support her.
    but i would never spend like 60 bucks
    to see her in concert 30 is the max…maybe…

    :D

  • AnnaMorgause

    here comes the fuckin haterz!
    you guys act like shes the worst singer in the world.
    i can admit that some notes were off tune but im not gonna sit here and trash talk her when i kno she prob can sing better than me and im pretty sure she can sing way better than all of you.she obviously has way more talent than all of you thats for sure!

    Most of us aren’t saying that she’s the worst. We’re saying the truth, that she’s average

    Average, by comparison to really distinctive voices like Demi’s, Miley’s and JB’s can seem really bad, but really isn’t.

    And yes, her voice is better than mine, but I’m not going to win American Idol any time soon

  • Erin Blom

    Well, i thought it was good, i liked the end more than the start. But i do think some of the people are over-exaggerating. I’m no fan or a hater, i never seemed interested in her. But the haters don’t like her, so obviously the ones who over-exaggerated probably forced themselves to hate it. I wouldn’t say she’s the best singer, but she can sing. And she doesn’t have much experience like most musicians.

  • missi

    I don’t understand why people like you waste money on things they know are bad. Like I love the state of Florida but I’m not gonna buy a rotten orange to “support them”.

  • lo

    she is SO damn annoying…stop laughing at stupid things and stop acting like you are a musician

  • Anonymous77889876545567

    SUCKALICIOUS!!!

    i stepped on my cat’s foot tonight, let me tell you, the cat sounded better than selena, in fact her ears started twitching when selena was singing

  • maria jay

    her voice sucks, tbh. now i’m out before selena fans can argue about how amazing and grammy-winning that was. later fools.

  • nickj.davidh.mitchelm.joej.kevinj

    you haters -.-‘
    she sounds good
    god you CANT compare her with demi or miley, you morons . she just started
    when i hitted play i thought disappointment will rush through me then i realized it wasnt THAT bad though the ‘you’s are not the best thing ever..

  • amberr

    Are you serious? If this is true, that’s so rude

    hah, Selena is so fake, its kinda funny.

  • emmmuh

    wow, give the girl a break. i think she’s good, she was probably really nervous cause it was the first time she’s sung live in front of fans? theres a lot of difficult notes in that song & of course it wasnt going to be perfect. i still love selena and i love falling down :)

  • Erin Blom

    that makes it even worse. she gets a record deal handed to her and doesn’t take it seriously at all, while struggling TALENTED singers can’t even book a performance. awful.

    thats because Selena is already known, so it probably is easy for her.

    Maybe if i heard two-three more songs acoustic i might go buy the album – cause i already liked the preview of their song, “I got yo”

  • amberr

    wtf did i just listen to
    sounded like some country song

    lmao

  • Anonymous!

    I laughed with I heard this, finally we get to hear her live. She did as bad as I expected. I think she’d sound great if she gets a vocal coach.. which I thought she had one.

  • Anonymous

    epic. fail.

  • sweettooth

    oh my goodness that made me literally laugh out loud..im still laughing haha oh gosh thank you

  • Anonymousaaaa

    just started? uhh yeah, just started in 2006. even before then if u count barney.

  • corn pops boi!!!

    it started of bad but it ended up actually really good for me…im definately getting her cd and going to her concert :)

  • Anonymous

    Please spend your money on artists who actually deserve their record deals.

  • true

    she is ….. ok

  • ashleyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

    stick to acting.

  • Wonder-Never-Land

    Honestly, Selena didn’t even sound that bad. Sure, she messed up like two or three times; but overall she did a decent job. Heck, even the most experienced, successful singers can give a weak performance, but other times they don’t. They can’t be perfect in every performance they do. Like NICK JONAS for example, he completely SUCKED when he sang “Catch Me”, it was really terrible, but there are times when he does give a good performance.

    You guys need to give Selena a break! She’s new to all this, she’s a beginner and I think people should really give her a chance. I’m sure with more practice, she would do better in her future performances. Sure, her voice may not be “powerful”, but she CAN sing, she just needs some work and she’ll be fine. I remember when MILEY CYRUS started out and she really wasn’t that good in the beginning, but now she has improved so much. So like I said, give Selena a break and give her a chance! She knows she doesn’t sound like Christina Aguilera, she knows that acting is more of a strong point for her, but she just wants to try her hands with music and wants to make fun, enjoyable songs for her fans. She doesn’t care how much her album sales, she just wants her fans to like them.

  • Maddison

    Fucking AMEN!!!

  • IHeartNewYork.

    Holy fuck, my ears are bleeding. That was so off tone, and just goes to show how edited her voice is.

  • Amy :]

    Lol damn that sucked. I have a sort-of friend who is planning on going to her concerts and buying her CD to “support her” even though she admits her voice sucked. Meanwhile, when I invited her to go to a Demi concert with me, she thought it was “too much money”. Of course.

  • Europe

    WHY ARE HATERS SO OBSESSED WITH HATING SELENA?

    i never understood people who were that obsessed. I’m not a Selena Fan/Hater just a person who is a newbie here.

    I don’t think Selena is a good singer nor a bad singer. She just needs a bit of time, and practice. I mean i think “I Got U” would sound really good live but not songs like “Stop and Erase”….I just hope Selena would choose songs that suit her voice like the more soul, softer, slower (whatever u call it) songs. I hated “Tell me something” but really liked “Fly to your heart.

  • felipetita

    S*UCK IT HATERS!!!

    She is an AMAZING actress, and a good singer!

    SELENA <3

  • Anonymous

    mate, are you deaf?

  • follow@monicaabbb

    did the guy tell her to pull up her shirt?

  • cailly

    the drummer said he would be peter from family guy for a day, i think i’m in love lol

  • animeGuurrl

    Eh, Selena can sing. she just has flaws, just like every other Disney star.

    Demi – shouts, yells and screams.
    Miley – too husky, raspy and deep at times.
    Nick – too whiny and his voice always cracks.
    Joe – plain and dull.
    Selena – kinda weak

    so yeah, Selena is right up there with them.

  • laurenmaria

    animeGuurrl said:
    Eh, Selena can sing. she just has flaws, just like every other Disney star.

    Demi – shouts, yells and screams.
    Miley – too husky, raspy and deep at times.
    Nick – too whiny and his voice always cracks.
    Joe – plain and dull.
    Selena – kinda weak

    so yeah, Selena is right up there with them.
    __________

    “Selena is right up there with them.”

    sweetheart, you better be kidding me with that shit. when it comes to singing, Selena CAN’T TOUCH Demi no matter how many vocal flaws you think Demi has. hell even though Nick and Joe are nothing amazing they can clearly sing better than Sel.
    get you ears cleaned out, then try again. kthanks.

  • nessarose

    poor selena. poor poor selena.

  • nessarose

    and stick to what you know.

  • ilovesellysel

    she was fine.

  • avi

    Eh, Selena can sing. she just has flaws, just like every other Disney star.

    Demi – shouts, yells and screams.
    Miley – too husky, raspy and deep at times.
    Nick – too whiny and his voice always cracks.
    Joe – plain and dull.
    Selena – kinda weak

    so yeah, Selena is right up there with them.
    ————-

    lol thats so true i love you for writing that, selena’s an ok singer but she an great actress(:

  • Anonymouss

    that was so bad i couldn’t finish it.

    seriously just stop. to sing you actually need talent. selena is the type of girl that if she went to american idol, all judges would say no in a second….and im not a hater…i really like selena and her acting but there are so many talented and amazing singers out there that don’t get opportunities like this one, and she doesn’t deserve it, at least not in the singing department haha

  • Anonymousy554

    That was extremely awkward to watch…this girl can’t sing, why are they making her sing? :( this was bad. ah. poor selena

  • laurenmaria

    don’t like Selena all that much but the live chat was prettyy darn funny.
    the guys on the far left is HOT and funny and so is the guy sitting to the right of her. anyone know their names and twitters?
    and as for her singing, i thought it was okay EXCEPT for the higher notes. they were horrible and very hard for me to listen too. other than that, she has a pretty, smooth voice.

    P.S. is it just me or is she not as pretty as she used to be? just my opinion.

  • kirsty

    hm , she got a good voice ..
    her song is addictive , if im jus sitting there it comes out for no reason :S lol .
    but yeah keep to singing (Y)

  • Blair Waldorf!

    don’t like Selena all that much but the live chat was prettyy darn funny.
    the guys on the far left is HOT and funny and so is the guy sitting to the right of her. anyone know their names and twitters?
    and as for her singing, i thought it was okay EXCEPT for the higher notes. they were horrible and very hard for me to listen too. other than that, she has a pretty, smooth voice.

    P.S. is it just me or is she not as pretty as she used to be? just my opinion.

    well, the guy on the far left is Greg, the one on the right on Selena is Ethan and The guy with Blonde curly hair is Joey. I’m not sure who’s the guy on the far right – he’s new though.

    Greg – twitter.com/greggarman

    Ethan – twitter.com/ethanisrad

    Joey – twitter.com/clemintville (sp? one of the other band member’s will be folowing him, so you can check there. lol)

    New guy – don’t know

  • evd

    i think she is adorable and deserves everything she achieves her singing is amazing for someone who has just started her voice reminds me of demi’s and i’d love to hear her sing more song like the way i loved you she sounds amazing. Its so so different thats why i dont compare her to of the already existing teenie bopper singers i think shes amazing and her next album will be even better. Once again we’re reminded by all the haters of all this shit about miley and demi fuck miley suucked in all her hannah whatever shit her voice in even see u again sucked. Demi wasnt so wow in moves me and her voice compared to get back then more recent shit like catch me is a massive milestone. I think sel is only going to sound better and her and her band get it all 2gether cant wait for the album and tour definitley be there and im an 18 y.o who loves my rnb so definitley a supporter of her sound but waiting for more ballad type slowish stuff it suits her voice more :) woowoo sel and the scene supporter for sure

  • Eliey

    animeGuurrl said:
    Eh, Selena can sing. she just has flaws, just like every other Disney star.

    Demi – shouts, yells and screams.
    Miley – too husky, raspy and deep at times.
    Nick – too whiny and his voice always cracks.
    Joe – plain and dull.
    Selena – kinda weak

    so yeah, Selena is right up there with them.
    __________

    “Selena is right up there with them.”

    sweetheart, you better be kidding me with that shit. when it comes to singing, Selena CAN’T TOUCH Demi no matter how many vocal flaws you think Demi has. hell even though Nick and Joe are nothing amazing they can clearly sing better than Sel.
    get you ears cleaned out, then try again. kthanks.

    lol. to the second girl – thats not even true. You’re talking about Demi as if she’s Elvis or something. Demi definately has flaws like she’d screeched too hard or something. Joe sometimes looses it when he sings. Nick – i donno!

    Selena has only sang once acoustically (to what i know) and you’re comparing her and Joe/Nick, who have sang millions live or something.

  • Blair Waldorf!

    Eh, Selena can sing. she just has flaws, just like every other Disney star.

    Demi – shouts, yells and screams.
    Miley – too husky, raspy and deep at times.
    Nick – too whiny and his voice always cracks.
    Joe – plain and dull.
    Selena – kinda weak

    so yeah, Selena is right up there with them.
    __________

    “Selena is right up there with them.”

    sweetheart, you better be kidding me with that shit. when it comes to singing, Selena CAN’T TOUCH Demi no matter how many vocal flaws you think Demi has. hell even though Nick and Joe are nothing amazing they can clearly sing better than Sel.
    get you ears cleaned out, then try again. kthanks.

    lol. to the second girl – thats not even true. You’re talking about Demi as if she’s Elvis or something. Demi definately has flaws like she’d screeched too hard or something. Joe sometimes looses it when he sings. Nick – i donno!

    Selena has only sang once acoustically (to what i know) and you’re comparing her and Joe/Nick, who have sang millions live or something.
    ———
    WIN!

    anyway, can someone tell me is it the same when a guy belly dances and a girl belly dances?

  • laurenmaria

    Blair Waldorf! said:

    well, the guy on the far left is Greg, the one on the right on Selena is Ethan and The guy with Blonde curly hair is Joey. I’m not sure who’s the guy on the far right – he’s new though.

    Greg – twitter.com/greggarman

    Ethan – twitter.com/ethanisrad

    Joey – twitter.com/clemintville (sp? one of the other band member’s will be folowing him, so you can check there. lol)

    New guy – don’t know
    __________

    omg i fucking love you.
    THANKS :)

  • STFU

    Okay, a lot of you guys are just freakin exaggerating. Stop being whiney, little bitches.

    I expected her to be terrible because of all the negative comments she got about her so-called “awful singing.” To be honest, I thought she did okay. It wasn’t HORRIBLE or anything like that.

  • Shenae

    Eh, Selena can sing. she just has flaws, just like every other Disney star.

    Demi – shouts, yells and screams.
    Miley – too husky, raspy and deep at times.
    Nick – too whiny and his voice always cracks.
    Joe – plain and dull.
    Selena – kinda weak

    so yeah, Selena is right up there with them.
    __________

    “Selena is right up there with them.”

    sweetheart, you better be kidding me with that shit. when it comes to singing, Selena CAN’T TOUCH Demi no matter how many vocal flaws you think Demi has. hell even though Nick and Joe are nothing amazing they can clearly sing better than Sel.
    get you ears cleaned out, then try again. kthanks.

    i know ur a Demi fan but Demi’s no MJ or Elvis that Selena can’t “touch”. But anyways, Demi is rock – Selena’s more pop. So no comparision there!

  • camille(:

    Not that great… she’s a really good actress though!! Just a no no on the singing.. :I

  • Blair Waldorf!

    well, the guy on the far left is Greg, the one on the right on Selena is Ethan and The guy with Blonde curly hair is Joey. I’m not sure who’s the guy on the far right – he’s new though.

    Greg – twitter.com/greggarman

    Ethan – twitter.com/ethanisrad

    Joey – twitter.com/clemintville (sp? one of the other band member’s will be folowing him, so you can check there. lol)

    New guy – don’t know
    __________

    omg i fucking love you.
    THANKS :)

    ur welcome! i think i’m in love with Greg. lol.

  • laurenmaria

    Eliey said:

    lol. to the second girl – thats not even true. You’re talking about Demi as if she’s Elvis or something. Demi definately has flaws like she’d screeched too hard or something. Joe sometimes looses it when he sings. Nick – i donno!

    Selena has only sang once acoustically (to what i know) and you’re comparing her and Joe/Nick, who have sang millions live or something.
    _________

    *sigh*
    i never said Demi’s voice was flawless.
    but if you honestly think that Demi is not a better singer than Selena, then i’m just not even gonna waste my time with someone as delusional as you.

  • jammy!

    Wonder-Never-Land said:

    Honestly, Selena didn’t even sound that bad. Sure, she messed up like two or three times; but overall she did a decent job. Heck, even the most experienced, successful singers can give a weak performance, but other times they don’t. They can’t be perfect in every performance they do. Like NICK JONAS for example, he completely SUCKED when he sang “Catch Me”, it was really terrible, but there are times when he does give a good performance.

    You guys need to give Selena a break! She’s new to all this, she’s a beginner and I think people should really give her a chance. I’m sure with more practice, she would do better in her future performances. Sure, her voice may not be “powerful”, but she CAN sing, she just needs some work and she’ll be fine. I remember when MILEY CYRUS started out and she really wasn’t that good in the beginning, but now she has improved so much. So like I said, give Selena a break and give her a chance! She knows she doesn’t sound like Christina Aguilera, she knows that acting is more of a strong point for her, but she just wants to try her hands with music and wants to make fun, enjoyable songs for her fans. She doesn’t care how much her album sales, she just wants her fans to like them
    ——————————-

    you’re one of the VERY FEW smart ones here.

  • Eliey

    lol. to the second girl – thats not even true. You’re talking about Demi as if she’s Elvis or something. Demi definately has flaws like she’d screeched too hard or something. Joe sometimes looses it when he sings. Nick – i donno!

    Selena has only sang once acoustically (to what i know) and you’re comparing her and Joe/Nick, who have sang millions live or something.
    _________

    *sigh*
    i never said Demi’s voice was flawless.
    but if you honestly think that Demi is not a better singer than Selena, then i’m just not even gonna waste my time with someone as delusional as you.

    i never said Demi was better than Selena. I’m just saying – Selena can be able to sing whatever Demi sings (in her own way)

    But Demi has more experience than Selena in singing, thats why Demi’s voice is better

    Selena has more experience than Demi in acting, thats why Selena’s a way better actress

  • Blair Waldorf!

    PLEASE ANSWER,

    is it the same when a guy belly dances and a girl belly dances?

  • laurenmaria

    Shenae said:

    i know ur a Demi fan but Demi’s no MJ or Elvis that Selena can’t “touch”. But anyways, Demi is rock – Selena’s more pop. So no comparision there!
    _______

    listen up teenie,
    i NEVER said Demi was “MJ or Elvis”.
    hahaha you’re just another delusional Selena fangirl. Demi sings pop as well. it’s called pop-rock. Demi is clearly the best singer on DC right now. just be mature and admit that. i never said Selena was a bad singer. she’s okay. not nearly as good as Demi though. Selena has even admitted that herself.

  • jammy!

    Selena’s voice reminds me of Ingrid Michaelson.

  • Shenae

    know ur a Demi fan but Demi’s no MJ or Elvis that Selena can’t “touch”. But anyways, Demi is rock – Selena’s more pop. So no comparision there!
    _______

    listen up teenie,
    i NEVER said Demi was “MJ or Elvis”.
    hahaha you’re just another delusional Selena fangirl. Demi sings pop as well. it’s called pop-rock. Demi is clearly the best singer on DC right now. just be mature and admit that. i never said Selena was a bad singer. she’s okay. not nearly as good as Demi though. Selena has even admitted that herself.

    you said, “Selena CAN’T TOUCH Demi no matter how many vocal flaws you think Demi has”

    uhh…Selena can’t touch MJ/Elvis (thats what i really meant) i’m sure she can touch Demi’s music in a different way.

  • laurenmaria

    Eliey said:

    i never said Demi was better than Selena. I’m just saying – Selena can be able to sing whatever Demi sings (in her own way)

    But Demi has more experience than Selena in singing, thats why Demi’s voice is better

    Selena has more experience than Demi in acting, thats why Selena’s a way better actress
    _________

    are you kidding me with this? how old are you? 8?
    YOU HAVE TO BE BORN WITH VOCAL TALENT.
    yes, you can improve your voice with practice but you can never be a good singer unless you were born with a great deal of vocal ability to begin with.
    Demi’s a better singer, just get over it k?

    at least i’m mature enough to admit that Selena is the better actress. Demi and Sel have actually been acting for the same amount of time. it’s just that acting is Selena’s special talent, while singing is Demi’s.
    get it? good.

  • Hay

    Selena’s voice reminds me of Ingrid Michaelson.

    who?

  • Eliey

    never said Demi was better than Selena. I’m just saying – Selena can be able to sing whatever Demi sings (in her own way)

    But Demi has more experience than Selena in singing, thats why Demi’s voice is better

    Selena has more experience than Demi in acting, thats why Selena’s a way better actress
    _________

    are you kidding me with this? how old are you? 8?
    YOU HAVE TO BE BORN WITH VOCAL TALENT.
    yes, you can improve your voice with practice but you can never be a good singer unless you were born with a great deal of vocal ability to begin with.
    Demi’s a better singer, just get over it k?

    at least i’m mature enough to admit that Selena is the better actress. Demi and Sel have actually been acting for the same amount of time. it’s just that acting is Selena’s special talent, while singing is Demi’s.
    get it? good.

    i never said Demi was a bad singer. And let me correct something, I said, “i never said Demi was better than Selena”…what i meant to say was “i never said Selena was better than Demi”

    Selena has done acting way more than singing thats why she has more experience. Demi has done singing way more than acting, thats why she has more experience in singing. Thats what i meant.

  • laurenmaria

    Shenae said:

    you said, “Selena CAN’T TOUCH Demi no matter how many vocal flaws you think Demi has”

    uhh…Selena can’t touch MJ/Elvis (thats what i really meant) i’m sure she can touch Demi’s music in a different way.
    _________

    you know what? this isn’t even worth getting into a fight over. if you honestly think Selena is anywhere near as good as Demi when it comes to singing, then CONGRATS, bitch! you’re officially delusional.

    ffs you Selena fangurrrls act as if i was like “SELENA IS THE WORST SINGER EVER” umm no. if you look higher up, i actually said that Sel’s voice was “pretty and smooth”. i’m not hating k? just admit that Demi’s the much better singer. at least give her that.

  • marshalll

    gotta say i like her as an actress but not so much as a singer. her voice is too weak here which is surprising because she has been training with a vocal coach for a couple of years now. i wouldnt buy her album.

  • laurenmaria

    Eliey said:

    i never said Demi was a bad singer. And let me correct something, I said, “i never said Demi was better than Selena”…what i meant to say was “i never said Selena was better than Demi”

    Selena has done acting way more than singing thats why she has more experience. Demi has done singing way more than acting, thats why she has more experience in singing. Thats what i meant.
    ___________

    “Selena has done acting way more than singing thats why she has more experience. Demi has done singing way more than acting, thats why she has more experience in singing.”

    hahaha no shit captain obvious.

  • laurenmaria

    Blair Waldorf! said:
    PLEASE ANSWER,

    is it the same when a guy belly dances and a girl belly dances?
    _______

    yep i’m pretty sure it’s the same.

  • Nickzgirl

    I think she was really good! well done selena!!! :)

  • Shenae

    you said, “Selena CAN’T TOUCH Demi no matter how many vocal flaws you think Demi has”

    uhh…Selena can’t touch MJ/Elvis (thats what i really meant) i’m sure she can touch Demi’s music in a different way.
    _________

    you know what? this isn’t even worth getting into a fight over. if you honestly think Selena is anywhere near as good as Demi when it comes to singing, then CONGRATS, bitch! you’re officially delusional.

    ffs you Selena fangurrrls act as if i was like “SELENA IS THE WORST SINGER EVER” umm no. if you look higher up, i actually said that Sel’s voice was “pretty and smooth”. i’m not hating k? just admit that Demi’s the much better singer. at least give her that.

    i don’t think Selena is a better singer than Demi. I’m just saying Selena CAN actually sing any of Demi’s song in her way – since Demi’s and Selena’s music is completely different. You said selena CAN’T touch Demi (music or voice)…but she can.

  • Blair Waldorf!

    PLEASE ANSWER,

    is it the same when a guy belly dances and a girl belly dances?
    _______

    yep i’m pretty sure it’s the same

    lol. i would like to see Greg do one. i wouldn’t know what to expect since i’ve never heard of a guy belly dance

  • Eliey

    i never said Demi was a bad singer. And let me correct something, I said, “i never said Demi was better than Selena”…what i meant to say was “i never said Selena was better than Demi”

    Selena has done acting way more than singing thats why she has more experience. Demi has done singing way more than acting, thats why she has more experience in singing. Thats what i meant.
    ___________

    “Selena has done acting way more than singing thats why she has more experience. Demi has done singing way more than acting, thats why she has more experience in singing.”

    hahaha no shit captain obvious.

    uhh…thats what i meant the first time i said it. but you just said something i didn’t understand!

  • laurenmaria

    Blair Waldorf! said:
    PLEASE ANSWER,

    is it the same when a guy belly dances and a girl belly dances?
    _______

    yep i’m pretty sure it’s the same

    lol. i would like to see Greg do one. i wouldn’t know what to expect since i’ve never heard of a guy belly dance
    ______

    haha ikr? me too.
    if he starts belly dancing at one of Selena’s shows, somebody better youtube that shit!

  • laurenmaria

    Shenae said:

    i don’t think Selena is a better singer than Demi. I’m just saying Selena CAN actually sing any of Demi’s song in her way – since Demi’s and Selena’s music is completely different. You said selena CAN’T touch Demi (music or voice)…but she can.
    _______

    hahahaha
    okay you know what? just nevermind.
    you don’t get it.

  • .

    eh. i think she sounds so odd because she’s trying to sing acoustic and sing the song differently. because she doesn’t sound like this on youtube, she actually sounds good on youtube. this wasn’t her best but give her time. stop being so mean to her, i’d love for you guys to sing live in front of 30,000 people and sound like x-tina if acting is your first talent. assholes. and honestly, if her album doesn’t sound like that, it’s no big deal. haters, man.

  • Blair Waldorf!

    PLEASE ANSWER,

    is it the same when a guy belly dances and a girl belly dances?
    _______

    yep i’m pretty sure it’s the same

    lol. i would like to see Greg do one. i wouldn’t know what to expect since i’ve never heard of a guy belly dance
    ______

    haha ikr? me too.
    if he starts belly dancing at one of Selena’s shows, somebody better youtube that shit!
    —-
    YES!

  • duceex3

    I’m not a Selena hater, but that wasn’t very good. Her talent is acting, not singing.

  • ANONYMOUS123456789

    She’s probably 100x better than all the haters dissin her. build a bridge and get over it

    she’s not the best but she just started singing, besides i didnt think it was that bad for struggling to sing with that really loud guitar. he could’ve played a bit quiter

  • Kathleen

    oh crap. i got goosebumps :|

  • animeGuurrl

    Um, my ears are fine thank you. and it’s MY opinion, I don’t have to agree with you. seriously, I think JB, Miley, Demi and Selena are all very average singers. they’re good enough for disney/teenybopper standards, but thats it.

  • Erin Blom

    Holy fuck, my ears are bleeding. That was so off tone, and just goes to show how edited her voice is.

    see, thats what i meant. People are over-exaggerating a lot. You can’t really bleed from your ears hearing a soft song.

  • Mandy.

    hah! Hater can now al go to hel where they belong.
    if this doesnt prove to you that Selena is an awesome singer then i dont know what will. you’re completely stupid if you think this was bad. Just stfu and stop being jealous becasue you can tsing as good as she can. Cant wait for the album Sel. and i loved the live chat :)

  • : )

    AMEN!
    shut the fuck up people.
    stop being such haters.

    she might not be the best singer
    but stop being jealous that shes rich & famous & your not.

  • anyyy

    okay, I am no singer. but I think I can do better than that!

  • lovejesus

    she cant sing… yay miley!

  • Blair Waldorf!

    epic. fail.

    hypocritical much?

  • Anonymous

    no. just not deaf like you lot are.

  • felipetita

    Miley’s fans are so ridiculous

    SELENA IS BETTER THAN SHE :D

  • Anonymousss

    haha excuse, uh.. Mandy? jealous of that voice?!!? you must be on some crack

  • Anonymous

    I expected her to be terrible, that actually wasn’t bad. So many good bands don’t have the most epic singers (I doubt Mick Jagger would’ve won American Idol, you know? NOT that I’m comparing the Stones to Selena Gomez…LOL…just saying, not all singers have angelic flawless voices)…no need to compare her to some other pop star. Does anyone know if she writes some/all of her own songs?

  • pft.

    i love reading comments first. it prepares me for the worst. for instance, i read eveything and figured ‘oh god, this is going to be a trainwreck.’ actually listened, and wasn’t really even close. people hyped me up for nothing. she did do pretty good. she actually does sound very close to her cd. if anything, to many people, she probably sounds better then taylor swift live.

    the bands funny.

  • Mayra.

    you people are mean to this poor girl!!! we know she is not a good singer but… ahh I´m not even gonna make a excuse…

  • hitler

    what!!!!

    complete FAIL

  • Blair Waldorf!

    Are you serious? If this is true, that’s so rude

    hah, Selena is so fake, its kinda funny.

    fake for being herself? fake for not having scandelous pictures? whats wrong with you people

  • Ammie

    So bad.

  • Anonymousdisneygrl

    epic. fail.

    hypocritical much?

    epic fail? are you serious?
    lets hear you sing talentless b*tch.
    get off this post.

  • AMY.

    she’s okaaay. i like her song.
    her voice is iiight.

  • Tonks

    Wow, that sounds nothing at all like the recorded version. I like her computerized voice better.

  • taylooorrr

    wooow. seriously i dont like selena gomez, but even if i did, i would still say that she SUCKS at singing. she needs to STICK TO ACTING.

  • Blair Waldorf!

    no. just not deaf like you lot are.

    what i meant was, you keep bashing me for coming to a miley post, and what are you doing? i think thats called “hypocritical”

  • pft.

    people are definitely over-exagerating. she did good if not better then most people expected.

  • Anonymous90909

    at least it doesn’t sound like every other disney pop song

  • oh dear

    she can’t sing.

  • Blair Waldorf!

    wooow. seriously i dont like selena gomez, but even if i did, i would still say that she SUCKS at singing. she needs to STICK TO ACTING.

    its mainly for the fans who will support her whether singing or acting.

  • Margrett

    CAn anyone say TONE DEAF??!?!?!?!?!

  • Anonymous

    i don’t recall ever having a conversation with you before.

  • lovely09

    SHE SUCKS!!!!!!

    NOBODY IS GOING TO BUY HER ALBUM “HER” SONGS ARE CRAPPY

  • iloveyou<3;

    No.
    Just… no.

  • lalalalalalala

    it could use some work, and is it me or you can only hear her band hitting the high notes.

  • omfg

    lord jesus please save me
    that was horrific
    absolutely 100% horfuckinific

  • 12

    lol i can’t get over that dumbass band name.

    but anyway.

    that sucked. not even gonna beat around the bush.

  • Mandy.

    lol and i bet all you who say she sucks thinks that miley is better? seriously its one thing to say she sucks, but to compare her to a girl who cant hit a decent note to save her life is quite possiblt the stupidest thing i have ever heard in my entire life. i understand saying demi, but miley? honestly gtfo!

  • Xiomy

    oh well…
    That was just sad.

  • Danny

    has she? sounds to me like she was just given a record deal like all the other disney twats.

    aren’t you always b***hing at the selena fans for coming to the miley posts – so why don’t get out of here

  • Anonymousomg

    I love sel but you need to practice a lot more :(

  • Emely :)

    Hahaha, I love Greg and Joey :D<3

  • Anonymous

    why does everyone keep saying this? i’m not even a fan of hers. is it because my name is anonymous? you do realize that if you just leave the name field blank, it registers anonymous as your name, yes?

  • simba

    mandy, you never cease to amaze me

  • Elly Belly

    Oh lord. That was… not…. good.

  • Anonymousdisneygrl

    AMEN!
    shut the fuck up people.
    stop being such haters.

    she might not be the best singer
    but stop being jealous that shes rich & famous & your not.
    ——
    omg i know people are so jealous of her! haha
    they act like shes the worst singer in the world. they are seriously mad because shes rich,famous,talented and pretty and they’re not :)

  • felipetita

    Are you serious? If this is true, that’s so rude

    hah, Selena is so fake, its kinda funny.

    fake for being herself? fake for not having scandelous pictures? whats wrong with you people

    I agree with the last comment
    Selena is sweet, not fake lol

  • pft.

    granted, i thought she did well. but i can promise you, comparing her to miley is not the solution it’ll only cause more hate. yea, a lot of miley fans are in here nd probably hating without even seeing the video but its not like selena fans dont do the same thing. you know she did well. all that matter. people who are over-exagerating like they just lost a left lung probably didnt watch the vid. to begin with.

  • vani6655

    you just shut up that was awful

  • Anonymousaaaa

    naww if we were all lovers the world would be filled with hippies.

    and i like the way i live. money corrupts people and fame deludes people into doing things they know they cant do

  • .

    i think she needs to leave acoustic (sp?) songs alone until her voice gets better. because she sounded not so good on the ftsk acoustic version of their song, “she’s a lady” or whatever the hell it is. but when she was singing accapella with that girl bridget, that baby, it’s cold song, she sounded good. and when she was singing that song with her cousin, she sounded good, and especially sounded good singing leavin’ by jesse mccartney. i think she just needs to find what she’s easier at singing. because yes, demi sounds good NOW but when she was trying to be like britney spears and sing pop stuff, she sounded okay but it did nothing for her voice and it was just awkward. selena doesn’t know her style yet, and obviously has the wrong people trying to help her. so give her a break with the “ears are bleeding” bullshit.

  • eonline2

    Stick to you day job.

  • Lilie

    Stop to be mean!!
    she sounds good!
    GO SELENA!!!!!

  • Love SELENA

    She doesn’t have an in-ear with her, that is why she hardly hear her voice,
    To me, she sounds a lot better than the ROBOT Miley.
    Her band is amazing, I’m so down for her tour, can’t wait for her album.
    Every song in her album is very catchy,…
    She has a good taste in music, her album is way better than I expect, to me it is,
    To haters, if you think it is not good, you have to think about Miley’s singing at the beginning. Selena will become better and better.

    Hope Selena will win ALMA, wish Selena all the luck.

  • kiara

    wow…that’s so sad. everyone..not one person i’ve seen said she’s good. =/

  • Love SELENA 4ever

    Anonymousdisneygrl said:
    AMEN!
    shut the fuck up people.
    stop being such haters.

    she might not be the best singer
    but stop being jealous that shes rich & famous & your not.
    ——
    omg i know people are so jealous of her! haha
    they act like shes the worst singer in the world. they are seriously mad because shes rich,famous,talented and pretty and they’re not :)
    *********

    I know right,

    You know this sucked website is kind of a battlefield,
    Selena’s fans will bash Miley’s posts and Miley’s fans will bash Selena’s posts.

    But all the fucking haters, listen:
    She is way better than ROBOT Miley, Her voice might be not as strong as Demi, but her soft voice is unique, and that is why I love it. Demi always screams in her songs, I hate it, fucking hate it. Make me headache.

    Demi’s acting is suck suck suck. To many people Demi’s singing is good, but to me I hate it.

    No one can please everyone, so shut the fuck up,

    Selena didn’t have her in-ear headphone so it’s kind of hard for her to hear her singing, wait till her tour, or her shows, you will she.
    She sounds great in her album.

  • line

    i think Selena is not as bad as you claim she is. do you guys know that Miley sounds that pitchy when she started? if you dont believe me, go check it out. :D

    Selena, Miley and Demi are good in several aspects. however it is, you guys will never agree. because you guys are a fan of each. it doesnt matter who you like but the thing is people keep on bitching on selena, miley and demi when they are the talented ones. you guys have no rights to do so.

    just agree with me, i love all of them. no harm in loving all okay.

  • Love SELENA 4ever

    Anonymousdisneygrl said:
    AMEN!
    shut the fuck up people.
    stop being such haters.

    she might not be the best singer
    but stop being jealous that shes rich & famous & your not.
    ——
    omg i know people are so jealous of her! haha
    they act like shes the worst singer in the world. they are seriously mad because shes rich,famous,talented and pretty and they’re not :)
    *********

    I know right,

    You know this sucked website is kind of a battlefield,
    Selena’s fans will bash Miley’s posts and Miley’s fans will bash Selena’s posts.

    But all the fucking haters, listen:
    She is way better than ROBOT Miley, Her voice might be not as strong as Demi, but her soft voice is unique, and that is why I love it. Demi always screams in her songs, I hate it, fucking hate it. Make me headache.

    Demi’s acting is suck suck suck. To many people Demi’s singing is good, but to me I hate it.

    No one can please everyone, so shut the fuck up,

    Selena didn’t have her in-ear headphone so it’s kind of hard for her to hear her singing, wait till her tour, or her shows, you will she.
    She sounds great in her album.

  • Anonymousdisneygrl

    people follow me on twitter and i’ll follow you back.
    twitter.com/love_liyah

  • To fucking haters

    Haters stop being mean and jealous,

    She was probably nervous, she even said that’s was kind of not good at the end of the song.

    She sounds great in other songs in her youtube videos, because she feels free with her family.

  • Anonymous461754

    Thats a big NO!
    stick to acting.
    for all of us.
    …..
    she’ll never understand.

  • Mandii

    FIRST?! I LOVE SEL! FOLLOW ME! twitter.com/mandiijonas! <3

  • dood

    I kinda liked it. Not when she tried to hit those high notes though.

  • abracadabra

    i don’t even know what to say. yikes.

  • Lily:)

    Indeed, girl needs to practice.

    Like for a decade or something.

  • Blair Waldorf!

    SHE SUCKS!!!!!!

    NOBODY IS GOING TO BUY HER ALBUM “HER” SONGS ARE CRAPPY

    sheesh its you again. don’t you have some activity that a normal 10 year old would do. Like i said before – HER FANS ARE GONNA BUY THEM…its not meant for haters.

  • Anonymous666

    Anonymousdisneygrl said:
    AMEN!
    shut the fuck up people.
    stop being such haters.

    she might not be the best singer
    but stop being jealous that shes rich & famous & your not.
    ——
    omg i know people are so jealous of her! haha
    they act like shes the worst singer in the world. they are seriously mad because shes rich,famous,talented and pretty and they’re not :)
    *********

    I know right,

    You know this sucked website is kind of a battlefield,
    Selena’s fans will bash Miley’s posts and Miley’s fans will bash Selena’s posts.

    But all the fucking haters, listen:
    She is way better than ROBOT Miley, Her voice might be not as strong as Demi, but her soft voice is unique, and that is why I love it. Demi always screams in her songs, I hate it, fucking hate it. Make me headache.

    Demi’s acting is suck suck suck. To many people Demi’s singing is good, but to me I hate it.

    No one can please everyone, so shut the fuck up,

    Selena didn’t have her in-ear headphone so it’s kind of hard for her to hear her singing, wait till her tour, or her shows, you will she.
    She sounds great in her album.
    _____________________
    Ear in headphones is to help you to sing live better when you are singing to a bunch crowds because you can’t hear yourself singing.But Selena is just singing to a fucking camera,so headphones or not.IT DOESN’T MATTER.Robot Miley?More like Robot Selena,in her ellen degeneres interview every questions asked to her, I can predict EXACLY what she answered.

  • Anonymousgfd

    oh. :O
    defo not what i was exspecting.
    she is terrible
    but she is amazing at acting.
    & i think she is a great person.
    but i don’t think singing is her thing.
    maybe cause its one of her first times singing live for us. she was nervous maybe?
    or just something else&
    and needs more lessons.

    stick to acting selena!

  • YESSSSS

    BETTER THAN MILEY BY FAR
    STILL NEEDS PRACTICE BUT!
    SHE COULD BE AS GOOD AS DEMI
    IN TIME

  • simba

    haters arent the only ones who are exaggerating

  • mandaa

    that…that wasnt very good at all O_O
    and im legit a HUGE selena fan/supporter but yowww she really cant sing and…her band isnt too good :|
    sorry..

  • Anonymous. (:

    seriously. selena should just STICK TO ACTING.

  • um.

    Um, omg. No Just no. It shows how much they edited her voice, A LOT.

  • polia

    lol @ the delusional idiots on this post
    IT WAZ DA BEST SONG EVA!!! SOUNDS JUST LIKE HER CD!!! OMG SO TALENTED!!!

  • annoyeddddd.

    wow. no joke, i cringed. and im not even a hater. that was awfulllll.

  • ILOVEJONASSSSSS

    i actually like selena unlike miley and i am a big fan of hers but to be honest i think she should stick to acting. shes such a great actress and i dont know why she has to go ahead and sing..some people arent cut out for it..just becasue you’re a disney star dosent mean you have to sing.. miley is a bit better on the singing but not much of an improvment.. it actually hurts my eras to hear selena sing.. demi actually has singing and acting talent.

  • Madeline

    what the hell
    never sing live again
    my ears are bleeding

  • dnc

    all of you idiots on here saying she can’t sing are fucking dumb. and yeah, she’s not the best singer, but she can sing. and for those of you who are saying your ears are bleeding after you watched that, you clearly have some body malfunctions you need to take of, because ears just don’t bleed after watching videos, dumbasses.

  • :) :) :)

    She is an OK singer, she’s not HORRIBLE like most people say she is.

  • someone stole my name :(

    Stick to acting. For real. Please.