Vanessa Hudgens Winter Wonderland Full

Vanessa for sure. Selena sucks bid hairy donkey balls.

Vanessa's version is good. Selena just ruined the song -.-

AND i was first. Bow down bitcheesss!
Haha sorry, I was never first.

selena :)

I was trying to be first :\

Vanessa for sure, Selena gomez can't sing for shit. But selena is still my favorite disney girl.

SELENA RUINED IT. I HATE HER!!!!! SO MUCH! SHE SUCKS AT SINGING

VANESSA

DUH

You're Welcome !

vanessas voice is kinda annoying to me oh well they both suck sorry ! but i love them .. well to be true i forgot about vanessa but selena ya i like her

selena totally rocked it.
vanessa was ok i guess

selena ruined the song -.-

selena sounds really awesome :)

selenas.

Vanessa.

I didn't like Selena's version, cause it should have been a slow song instead of loud and up-beat.

selenas.

---------

In your goddamn fuckin dreams! Selena can go pleasure herself with a pickle. What a cunt.

I like music with Selena's version but Vanessa is a better singer:)

selenas.

---------

In your goddamn fuckin dreams! Selena can go pleasure herself with a pickle. What a cunt.
--
Everyone has their own opinion. You can't speak for everyone here.

Selena! what kind of stupis question is this. Vanessa is a terrible singer and actress!

Vanessa.

selenas.

---------

In your goddamn fuckin dreams! Selena can go pleasure herself with a pickle. What a cunt.
--
Everyone has their own opinion. You can't speak for everyone here.

----

Fuck you. This isnt your argument. Selena is a bitch and thats all there is to it.

SELENA !

Mandy said:

Selena! what kind of stupis question is this. Vanessa is a terrible singer and actress!
---
i agree ! and vanessa is so old

selena. She sounds really good ! lOVE HER

I think selena

selenas.

---------

In your goddamn fuckin dreams! Selena can go pleasure herself with a pickle. What a cunt.
--
Everyone has their own opinion. You can't speak for everyone here.

----

Fuck you. This isnt your argument. Selena is a bitch and thats all there is to it.
---
Geez...whatever!

selena ! She sounds better than she normally does

Vanessa was the best.Selena was ok.
Selena was too up beat for me.I like the calm type of christmas songs.And Vanessa kept it calm.And Vanessa's voice sounded pretty.

vanessa is 22

is that old?

English said:

selenas.

---------

In your goddamn fuckin dreams! Selena can go pleasure herself with a pickle. What a cunt.
--
Everyone has their own opinion. You can't speak for everyone here.

----

Fuck you. This isnt your argument. Selena is a bitch and thats all there is to it.
---
looks like somebody has some problems !! she or he is right everybody has hid own opinion just because its not like yours doesnt mean its wrong ! and selena is way better than you'll ever be !

MELENA

lisalionheart said:

selena ! She sounds better than she normally does
---

that's because it wasn't live

Mileyfan12345 said:

vanessa is 22

is that old?
---
i didnt mean age

SELENA RUINED THE FUCKING SONG
SHE CANT SING FOR SHIT
FUCK!

lolololol sorry, I just can't take vanessa seriously.

the comments on here are ridiculous. i prefer vanessa's version. but selena's version is good too.

selenas voice is much better but vanessas version sounds better because its more slowly....so both are great!

Vanessa all the way.

I like selena's a little better, only because I really like faster beats. Vanessa's is a little too slow for me, but it's mstill a really good cover :)

Vanessa..

I don't get why selena likes to do fast beats,since she is AMAZING when doing slow ones...but still, prefer selena's :) vanessa's voice was too annoying :\

LAS 2!
Selena & Vanessa!?
Cada quien con su version bldas! ahahah

Although i love Selena, Vanessa's version is better in my opinion because it's classic =)

vanessa's. at least she can keep in tune.

I don't like either of their voices. But Vanessa's voice is stronger and more controlled so I guess Vanessa.

i agree. i don't want rock kind of music in my christmas season. i like calm music in my winters. selena's was fine i just llike vanessa's better lol.

Vanessa!! At christmas you don't want to "rock out" you want nice calm music...
I like Vanessa voice better anyways it sounds better than Selenas...
And for whoever said Vanessa is "old" dude, she's only 21 if that's considered old I'd hate to think what actual old people are called :/

vanessa is like a rat on the toilet doing its thing

Vanessa is 20

I think the way Vanessa sang it was REALLY good. I actually like her singing in this song. Selena's version is cool too. But vanessa sang it better - more classical. We all have our different opinions.

Selena's version is more of my type of music, but Vanessa's was way better.
Selena cant sing.

Vanessa is "old" dude, she's only 21 if that's considered old I'd hate to think what actual old people are called :/
---
and dude i didnt mean the age !!!!! i meant kinda of a has been like last year ! not the age ! and old people are called old people

Vanessa, seriously, there is no competition. Selena ruined the song. I cannot take Selena seriously. She is going to be out of the Disney scene, then no one will know her.

SELENA <333

You guys shouldnt vote on who you like better.
Vanessa did an amazing version, selena ruind the song...
Everyone in his world vote's childish.

What a question???!?!?!?!
VANESSA!!!!!!
I love both (I really do) but V!

sels all the way.........it just sounds better all together...vannessa annoying........she keeps trying to stay in "hollywood" by doing crappy movies and songs to stay n the scene...

I love them both.But selena just ruined the song...Vanessa all the way...I like how she sing it slow and nice

VANESSA...duh...selena is my girl but she screwed p the song

selena's version was better it made me feel happy :) i mean i love nessa but it was too slow for me :) for sure sels x

I hate selena when she sings...vanessa is annoying too but i love how she sing the song...Selena should stick to acting

VANESSA FTW
selena ruined the song and she was even singing she was just saying the words. no talent

you ppl voting for selena are joking, right?

i like them both. vanessas because of her singing and selenas cuz of the beat but when selena went "yow!" or something at the end, it just ruined it... -.-''

Vanessa of course. there's not a doubt about that

Team VANESSA ANNE HUDGENS All THE WAY!!
The best singer
The best actress
And I don't care about what anyone nessa is the best

Selena's version is better. It's just more fun and upbeat. Plus, her singing voice is a bit more "unique" than Vanessa's and more recognizable.

Vanessa's version was just boring and dull. and her singing was a little too whiny.

None of them...ALy & AJ did a better job..

VANESSA!!! she has an amazing voice!:D she rocks! selena is good to but vanessa is better ;)

you ppl voting for selena are joking, right?
-----------------------------
Don't try and make it seem like Selena is the worst singer in the whole world because she's definitely not. Sure, she's no Christina Aguilera, but she CAN sing in her own right. I'm so sick and tired of you people always OVER-EXAGGERATING about her voice, she does not sound THAT bad so stop with your bullshit.

SELENA!!

duh they have their different versions..
i like vanessa's voice buh its too slow...
selena's like a little rock version..

i love her!! :]

I like both and wanna hear them collide in that song! It would be amazing!

VANESSA HUDGENSSSSSSSSS !!!!!!!1 selena doesnt know how to SING ! GET THE FACT !

Out of them two, I prefer Vanessa's.

But I do prefer Selena as a person, Vanessa kinda annoys me.

I would pick Selena ANY day!

i love both of them and they way they singed this song GO BABY V AND SELENNA

Vanessa. I think she sings very good, she know what she is doing, she is showing her voice with that jazz type song.
Selena's version is more easy to sing, her voice is kinda mix with the music. But I like both, one happy version and the other one mellow.

Please people, if you're going to vote base it on the singing and not who you like better, I totally love vanessa's version feels like more of a Christmas song than selenas, although selena is not the best singer she can sing slower songs so she should've taken advantage of that but whatever... I had a feeling that selena was going to lead this poll based on the factthat oceanup is filled with selena stans so...

Please people, if you're going to vote base it on the singing and not who you like better, I totally love vanessa's version feels like more of a Christmas song than selenas, although selena is not the best singer she can sing slower songs so she should've taken advantage of that but whatever... I had a feeling that selena was going to lead this poll based on the factthat oceanup is filled with selena stans so...

Please people, if you're going to vote base it on the singing and not who you like better, I totally love vanessa's version feels like more of a Christmas song than selenas, although selena is not the best singer she can sing slower songs so she should've taken advantage of that but whatever... I had a feeling that selena was going to lead this poll based on the factthat oceanup is filled with selena stans so...

i kinda like Selena's better... i like both versions, but Selena just gets me in the Christmas mood and Vanessa's kinda sounds annoying... just my opinion

Selena may have more fans but its totally clear that vanessa's version is better.

What a beautiful voice Vanessa. Congratulations.

Vanessa 10 x better

English said:

selenas.

---------

In your goddamn fuckin dreams! Selena can go pleasure herself with a pickle. What a cunt.
--
Everyone has their own opinion. You can't speak for everyone here.

----

Fuck you. This isnt your argument. Selena is a bitch and thats all there is to it.
---
looks like somebody has some problems !! she or he is right everybody has hid own opinion just because its not li

ke yours doesnt mean its wrong ! and selena is way better than you'll ever be !

MELENA

____

VANESSA IS WAY BETTER

jaja you are NOT!

Selena!!!

and for everyone who is arguing on here,get a fuckin life. there is no need to cuss people out and say rude stuff about selena and vanessa. be mature.

Well, I love Selena, but her version is weird. Vanessa wins this round..

Anonymous said:

English said:

selenas.

---------

In your goddamn fuckin dreams! Selena can go pleasure herself with a pickle. What a cunt.
--
Everyone has their own opinion. You can't speak for everyone here.

----

Fuck you. This isnt your argument. Selena is a bitch and thats all there is to it.
---
looks like somebody has some problems !! she or he is right everybody has hid own opinion just because its not li

ke yours doesnt mean its wrong ! and selena is way better than you'll ever be !

MELENA

____

VANESSA IS WAY BETTER
---
ya well thats your opinion ! selena was better who is vanessa anyways ?

milessa said:

Team VANESSA ANNE HUDGENS All THE WAY!!
The best singer
The best actress
And I don't care about what anyone nessa is the best
---
ya thats why her albums suck cause shes a great singer and the best !
and thats why she didnt get a role in twilight

Ok so I think both of them are VERY good. I give them both ALOT of credit. Vanessa's is closer to the regular version and a lot more calm and selena kind of reinvented it and its a little more rocker but they are BOTH very good.

Selena.
It's a new take on a classic song.
Vanessa's version has been done before.
I could barely want to finish listening to the song.
I've heard that version too many times.

On another note:
Vanessa and Selena both can sing.
I say that if you can carry a tune, you can sing.
The thing is, Vanessa's voice is really sweet sounding, and even on a song sounding like this, it doesn't fit.
The way Selena sung her version of the song made it... work?
It just sounded more fitting to my ears.

And again, MY EARS.
Which means MY OPINION.

i like both versions, v has a beautiful voice and selena made the song rock

Wow. Selenais winning?? NO WAY. she can't SING. disney is so stupid... they're just trying to make as much money as they can out of all their stars. UGH. she can't sing at allll. on the other hand Vanessa Hudgens CAN sing, i luv her voice. And i really do like selena, just not her singing.

GAH! I hate Selena Gomez now! I used to be a fan of hers before but now she thinks she can do anything. Sing, design etc. She's a horrible singer and needs to come back to reality. I dislike Vanessa Hudgens a lot too, but I say her version is wayyyy better.

what the?! selena winning the polls? it's obvious V has a better voice than selena!!.. duh!! i love them both but when it comes to singing i'd vote for V. I bet people just voted for Sel because they don't like V. URGH! haters! the poll ask who sung it better not who do you like better!!! vote even people!!

So wat you're saying is that whoever's not in twilight is not a good actor/actress?? Please make a better argument... I mean I liked the books but the movies are just too overated... Haha.. But if you're referring to the rumour of Vanessa auditioning for new moon you're wrong in saying she didn't get in because she DIDNT even audition so it fails at
both aspects... Unless... It's another completely different meaning, if so please do explain lol

vanessas version was better
shes a real singer
selena cant sing at all.

I Like Vanessa more for christmas. Cuz it more calm. But i still like Selena`s verison..I be dancing in my room with selena`s

Vanessa sounds wayyy better. I like selena but not really as a singer.

Honestly, I love how upbeat Selena's version is. Vanessa's is good too, but I don't see much originality in it.

love vanessas because it was classic and her voice really fits the song and her voice is beautiful and wonderful but selena was good to but she just didnt need to remix it

this is a competition...how? one was hired as actress/singer/dancer, and the other was hired as actress now wannabe singer

I think they were both pretty good. I like Selena's cause it's more up beat. I like Vanessa's because her's sounds more mature in the voice range and she hit the high notes very well. They were both really good.

"FIRST!" is for bucktooth sissies.

Selena ftw.

I personally think Vanessa's was better and after reading the comments, MOSTLY everyone thinks so too, but the poll says something completely different! Selena's version was nice too, but like many of you said, it's doesn't sound "Christmas-y".

Vanessa's got my vote :)

I personally think Vanessa's was better and after reading the comments, MOSTLY everyone thinks so too, but the poll says something completely different! Selena's version was nice too, but like many of you said, it's doesn't sound "Christmas-y".

Vanessa's got my vote :)

I love Selena, but I never think she can sing. Vanessa's better for sure (& that's why I voted for her), but I've been listening to Aly & Aj's version of this song, & I personally think it's better (especially cuz it's got the part: "Over the ground...")

Oh & I understand that a lot of you want them to have some originality in the song, but I think for Christmas, the classic version is always the best :)

I can't stand all of the raspy air breathing every time selena sings. Vanessa's version is SO MUCH smoother!

luuv vanessas version

Vanessa, but I Love them both! But tell the truth Vaneesa is the better singer....

WOW SELENA FANS NEED TO GET THEIR HEAD OUT OF SELENA'S ASS AND LISTEN CLOSELY TO THE BEAUTIFUL VOICE OF ...... VANESSA ANNE HUDGENS AND ITS BETTER CUS ITS LIVE AND SELENA'S IS A BIG FUCKEN EDITED PIECE OF SHIT OH YEAH THATS RIGHT I WENT THERE BITCHEZ

what the?! selena winning the polls? it's obvious V has a better voice than selena!!.. duh!! i love them both but when it comes to singing i'd vote for V. I bet people just voted for Sel because they don't like V. URGH! haters! the poll ask who sung it better not who do you like better!!! vote even people!
====================

Obvious? Honey, it's a matter of OPINION. I think Selena sings better than Vanessa. Vanessa sounds like every other girl with that high-pitched, whiny chipmunky voice. Selena's voice is more light, soft, yet it has that little huskiness.

Besides, Vanessa's version of the song is way too boring and generic.

Selena's version is more fun and energetic.

They voted on which singer sang better and which version sounded better and most of them obviously picked Selena. So get over it!

Selena Gomez FTW!

i liked selena's better....

If you like to listening to an autotuned mess of a singer, then you'd like Selena's. Selena ruins it by speeding up the song and overstressing her voice on all the notes, so she tires easily. Vanessa, on the other hand, is a better singer. Vanessa's voice is more suitable for the song, because she can pull off the jazzy sound. Selena would probably never be able to sing like that.. she's always off tune. Lol. So, in the end, Vanessa beats the hell out of Selena, if you look at it technically.

The Gutair sounds like Carrie Underwoods song Cowboy Casnova

If you like to listening to an autotuned mess of a singer, then you'd like Selena's. Selena ruins it by speeding up the song and overstressing her voice on all the notes, so she tires easily. Vanessa, on the other hand, is a better singer. Vanessa's voice is more suitable for the song, because she can pull off the jazzy sound. Selena would probably never be able to sing like that.. she's always off tune. Lol. So, in the end, Vanessa beats the hell out of Selena, if you look at it technically.
------------------------------

Selena doesn't need autotune. She sang LIVE like a million times and she sounds the same as she does in her album and in this song.

It's pretty clear that Selena's voice is best suited for a slow, acoustic song, but Vanessa will NEVER pull off the rock/pop type.

Seriously, the only reason why you're so bitter about Selena's singing is because most people prefer it over Vanessa's. Get over it, people have different opinions!

Not really. It's common knowledge that oceanup is filled with Selena stans.

Pathetic bitch.
Find another hobby that will help make you feel useful.
Coward.

I gotta say when demi said people on gossip sites are mean she wasn't kidding!
i mean oh my god you guys are so mean..

I like Vanessa,I like Selena but Im the person that isnt much into slow songs...so yeah Selena,
but we all have our opinions and a lot of people like Selenas a lot like Vanessas so stop talking shit about selena-she did anything to you and you cant just say that you dont like her cause shes copiying whoever

what did she ever do to you?if she wants to sing let her sing!let her see for herself if shes good or bad.but for me shes actually good mostly on her i want it that way cover.but we all have our opinions

i love selena's cover, but vanessa sings better :)

Selena gomez is the number 1

Vanessa's version is way better and even her voice... i love selena but seriously she can't sing...

Vanessa. haha.

but i still LOVE Selena! <3

Stephanie said:

I think the way Vanessa sang it was REALLY good. I actually like her singing in this song. Selena's version is cool too. But vanessa sang it better - more classical. We all have our different opinions.
-------------------

Exactly. (:

I like Vanessa deff better.
I'm not a Selena-hater, but it's too much of a pop-bubblegum thing...
I really like Vanessa here. She sings it so warm and it really gets me in a Christmas-Mood!

Arwhg..Some people..

They want to know who sings it better.
They don't ask to choose between Vanessa and Selena as persons!
I think Vanessa sung it better.
And with that I mean that it's more Christmas-like.

Vanessa, she sang it with the genuine slow, quiet tune, the way it's supposed to be sang. THE way it's supposed to give you a good, warm, cosy feeling.
Selena's one was loud, annoying and too rock. Destroyed the song without even ONE implementation. Sucked. What was the use of listening to a happy song that was made into a pop tune?
I'm totally Selena's biggest fan. But fans know went to be judgemental, when to have opinions. I love Selena

Who even cares? There both human beings, living their dreams and doing a lot more than you ever will. They're both talented, don't compare them.

Fuck you. This isnt your argument. Selena is a bitch and thats all there is to it.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Because I'm sure you've been emotionally damaged by Selena Gomez, and that's why you're calling her a bitch. FUCK YOU.

in a way i like both...i liked vannessa's slow version and i like the edge on selenas soooo??? :)

Vanessa.
Selena ruined the song. She ruins every song. She just turned the song into a poopy-pop song.

On the other hand, Vanessa's was beautiful. The way it should be. (:

Team VANESSA ANNE HUDGENS All THE WAY!!
The best singer
The best actress
And I don't care about what anyone nessa is the best
---
ya thats why her albums suck cause shes a great singer and the best !
and thats why she didnt get a role in twilight
--------
she never sign up for Twilight dumbass.

If you like to listening to an autotuned mess of a singer, then you'd like Selena's. Selena ruins it by speeding up the song and overstressing her voice on all the notes, so she tires easily. Vanessa, on the other hand, is a better singer. Vanessa's voice is more suitable for the song, because she can pull off the jazzy sound. Selena would probably never be able to sing like that.. she's always off tune. Lol. So, in the end, Vanessa beats the hell out of Selena, if you look at it technically.
------------------------------

Selena doesn't need autotune. She sang LIVE like a million times and she sounds the same as she does in her album and in this song.

It's pretty clear that Selena's voice is best suited for a slow, acoustic song, but Vanessa will NEVER pull off the rock/pop type.
___________________________

Are you kidding? She needs the auto-tune more than ever. If there were no auto-tune, she wouldn't sound good on her records and no singing career. I bet she uses auto-tune when she's singing live.
Have you heard her sang acoustic? She sounds more horrible than scratching chalkboard.

At least Vanessa can sing unlike that untalented chick.

vanessa's jazzy version is a million times better than selena's. no contest.

Team VANESSA ANNE HUDGENS All THE WAY!!
The best singer
The best actress
And I don't care about what anyone nessa is the best
---
ya thats why her albums suck cause shes a great singer and the best !
and thats why she didnt get a role in twilight
---------------------
omg, HAHAHAHA. Are you serious? Check your facts, damaged kid. It was just a rumor about Twilight, the producers NEVER wanted Leah to be in the movie. Now who sucks? You.
Damn, you haters piss me off.

sels all the way.........it just sounds better all together...vannessa annoying........she keeps trying to stay in "hollywood" by doing crappy movies and songs to stay n the scene...
----------------------------
Doing crappy movies? O.o WTF. If you can't watch anything that's out of Disney it's your problem. Don't want to bash Selena, but seriously you can't tell that she has a better carrier than Vanessa does. Vanessa has two upcoming movies, I'm sure a lot people will watch. Selena has an upcoming music video for her song. Hmmm...
Seriously.

I love them both but I just don't like either of the songs. If Selena sang Vanessa's version it'd be much better.

Vanessa's version is way better!
I like Selena, but she just can't sing like Vanessa.
Vanessa's voice is the best! *-* And it was supposed to be a slow song..
I LOVE U VANESSA, FOREVER!

VANESSA!!
selena ruins the song, she cant sing anything

Vanessa's version is much better. This Christmas will rock with Baby V's new song!!! <3

ugh these gay tweenies dont know talent (im 17 years old so im not tweeny but come on oceanup to read some decent teen celeb gossip)
they vote selena cause they like her and havent been around long enough during the HSM1 days
winter wonderland is a classic and should be sung they way vanessa sang it
vanessa's was way better and sung beautifully like a professional
selena's vocals are too soft, low, and weak i can barely hear unless i turned up the volume
vanessa's is more louder while still acoustic
this poll is rigged plus the article is tagged under selena only
Vanessa's is version is way better than selena contest or not

fuck selena gomez you dumb tweenys were obviously not around when vanessa first came out (those were the days)
shes the better singer & actress
vanessa sings so much beautiful and better than selena any day

I like music with Selena's version but Vanessa is a better singer:)

--
I agree with this !

she never auditioned for twilight.