Kelly Clarkson SLAMS Taylor Swift Camp

  • jazylin

    Well said.

  • jamie

    i like ur icon…i love kristin and stephen!

  • Soyummii//??

    Kelly winning that show is hard work!
    She beat out millions of people,
    buh singing her guts out,
    You know how hard it is too even get on amercian idol?

  • Anonymous

    But was it really hard work? Taylor’s dad invested 1 million dollars in Big Machine Records so they would sign Taylor.

  • Anonymous

    Exactly. He’s a silent partner. Her label before didn’t want her singing, and it’s pretty obvious why. She can’t. But money talks and bullshit walks, so Scott Borchetta signed her. She sounds pretty on recordings but she just cannot sing at all. I’m tired of the nerves excuses too. Those girls who sang on VH1 divas had to sing with Martina, Sheryl, Melissa, Cindi, and they all blew it out of the water.

  • Anonymous

    This is just another instance of a spoiled rich kid getting whatever she wants because of her family’s money. Do people really think that if she came from a middle class background, she would have the career she does today? She probably wouldn’t even have a record deal, let alone 4 Grammys.

  • Anonymous

    It’s just sad because she can’t sing. If she could there’d be less venom. But people are tired of being taken for a ride. I can accept a lot of things in live performances. A flat note here and there, fine. Everyone has an off night. Hoarsness, yeah, voices get tired. But singing off key every performances, that’s asking way too much. She’s a singer who can’t sing but has her career because Big Machine couldn’t resist the allure of Scott Swift’s offer. Part of me wonders if the songs are even written by her since she doesn’t have any sense of pitch and can’t tune her guitar.

  • Anonymous

    There are so many talented people who go under the radar, so many amazing albums that came out this year, but this heaping helping of mediocrity gets 4 awards, including the biggest prize of the night? Bullshit. Honestly, I’m shocked that she has a successful headlining tour. Who would want to listen to her off-key wailing for two and a half hours?!

  • ERIN

    EIGHTH!!!!

  • Anonymous

    NINTH!!!!

  • ERIN

    TENTH!!! SOMEONE STOP ME IM ON A ROLL

  • your mom was here

    this computer is dead.. the video isnt loading :/

  • ERIN

    ELEVENTH

  • litetime

    Oceanup is like loosing all of the people that used to comment on here. It’s so crazy. I might have to find another gossip site to linger on, but then agai, this one is way too addicting

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous said:

    Well done Kelly!
    I love her for hacing the guts to tell the truth we all should already know.
    I have nothing against taylor swift, but she really can’t sing. she sounds awful, especially live.
    —————————–

    i totally disagree with you i just saw her in concert on thursday and she sounded absolutley amazing she was so good…..there was nothing wrong with her voice and her songs are awesome and she is such a great person so could everyone stop slamming her and ive heard kelly clarkson live and she dont sound that great at all so she should shove her comment up her ass :D

  • If the moon fell down tonight

    My hero :)

  • Heartless

    hahahaha

  • If the moon fell down tonight

    Oceanup is like loosing all of the people that used to comment on here. It’s so crazy. I might have to find another gossip site to linger on, but then agai, this one is way too addicting
    ……………..
    Agreed, with everything.

  • Kourtney

    this just happened I think yesterday, and I’m already tired of hearing about it -_-

  • If the moon fell down tonight

    this just happened I think yesterday, and I’m already tired of hearing about it -_-
    …………..
    Your icon doesn’t really make Taylor look pretty :/

  • If the moon fell down tonight

    I love Kelly for having guts :)
    She’s the best eveeerr.

  • Kourtney

    If the moon fel… said:
    Your icon doesn’t really make Taylor look pretty :/
    ******
    I don’t really care what you think, you’re that person that was rude to me yesterday. have a nice day

  • Anonymous

    Well done Kelly!
    I love her for hacing the guts to tell the truth we all should already know.
    I have nothing against taylor swift, but she really can’t sing. she sounds awful, especially live.

  • Anonymous

    *having

    sorry.

  • Anonymous

    I worship you Kelly for this comment. Taylor like JB in 08, and most likely Justin Beiber as well, is nothing more than a “novelty” right now. She has her success and that will be it, by her next album no one will care anymore because people will finally realize how much she sucks. The only tweener that has been successfully consistent is Miley.

  • HeyYouOkayNot

    Wasssup :P
    How is going your day?

  • Anonymous

    FOLLOW TO WIN A NICK JONAS CD!
    http://twitter.com/UKJonasBros

    FOLLOW TO WIN A NICK JONAS CD!
    http://twitter.com/UKJonasBros

    FOLLOW TO WIN A NICK JONAS CD!
    http://twitter.com/UKJonasBros

    FOLLOW TO WIN A NICK JONAS CD!
    http://twitter.com/UKJonasBros

  • Heartless

    Anonymous said:

    Well done Kelly!
    I love her for hacing the guts to tell the truth we all should already know.
    I have nothing against taylor swift, but she really can’t sing. she sounds awful, especially live.

    ———
    no i love her voice it’s beautiful

  • No Bitchassness

    Taylor swift is in a completely different league from amazing performers who performed before her on the Grammy’s

  • Heartless

    Anonymous said:

    FOLLOW TO WIN A NICK JONAS CD!
    http://twitter.com/UKJonasBros

    FOLLOW TO WIN A NICK JONAS CD!
    http://twitter.com/UKJonasBros

    FOLLOW TO WIN A NICK JONAS CD!
    http://twitter.com/UKJonasBros

    FOLLOW TO WIN A NICK JONAS CD!
    http://twitter.com/UKJonasBros
    ———-
    PLEASE STOP PLEASEEEEEEEEEEE

  • HeyYouOkayNot

    Feb 5, 2010 @ 11:05 am
    No Bitchassness said:

    Taylor swift is in a completely different league from amazing performers who performed before her on the Grammy’s
    —–
    This

  • emmbugg

    I’d rather be known for hard work than known for winning a competition show.
    Though Kelly is an amazing singer!!! :]

  • Mercedes

    that’s right kelly!! you tell that man to take his comments & stick it up his ass :)

  • abbey

    Everyone that is defening her is just saying stuff like, well she can sing live in concerts just fine. It’s called auto tuning! They can do that to microphones in concerts you know. That’s why at EVERY SINGLE live performance you hear her on she sounds so bad because it isn’t auto tuned.

    But of course fans that are so far up taylors ass just keep denying it.

  • Anonymous

    lol i love kelly for this!

  • I am who i am whatever that means

    I’m just fed up with people equating being talented with being a role model. Janis Joplin was fucked up 1000 ways from Sunday, but damn if she wasn’t talented. Elvis, same. John Lennon, the list goes on. Granted they weren’t teen entertainers but I think it holds. How “good” you are as a person has zero to do with your God given talent, or lack thereof.
    _____________
    I love you! you took these words right out of mouth. I was watching a debate yesterday about this and a woman said and i quote ” she may not be a good singer but she a good role model”…and i was like what being a role model has nothing to do with your ability to sing and shouldn’t be in the same sentence! Give a her medal for being a role model but when it comes to grammies give it to people who can actualy sing.

  • musiciseverything

    I personally love music from the 70’s and 80’s. Oh and the 60’s as well. I just can’t stand today’s music. It pisses me off. Auto-tuned voices and crappy lyrics to the fullest. Like really? Who could listen to that all day? Not me.

  • KellyLovesJoeJ

    Soo Tell Me this, If she cant hit the high notes and the right notes, the why is she winning all these fuckinggg awards when her voice is REMIXED?!?!?
    THANK YOU KELLY FOR SOMEONE SPEAKING UP!

  • IHeartNewYork.

    I agree with you. People are really so far up Taylor’s ass, it’s practically impossible for them to come out. Taylor Swift may be amazing at other things, but singing just isn’t one of them.

  • Anonymous

    Taylor Swift can’t sing for shit.

    but her songs are catchy

    but i am kind of tired of her singing about fairytales and boys so annoying

  • ET

    I’ve loved Kelly since American Idol, buuuuut this wasn’t Taylor, it was her aggent. So you can’t blame Taylor, but I agree with her. The Dude was rude.

  • HyperMe

    You go, Kelly!

  • Molly

    Feb 5, 2010 @ 11:20 am
    Anonymous said:

    abbey
    Feb 5, 2010 @ 11:14 am
    abbey said:

    Everyone that is defening her is just saying stuff like, well she can sing live in concerts just fine. It’s called auto tuning! They can do that to microphones in concerts you know. That’s why at EVERY SINGLE live performance you hear her on she sounds so bad because it isn’t auto tuned.

    But of course fans that are so far up taylors ass just keep denying it.

    ____________________-

    you’re also hilarious. hope you realize that every artist out there is equally auto-tuned so your argument has no purpose. there is still something to be said in the fact that she micromanages her entire career. writes her own music, manages her own tours, EVERYTHING. most singers do very little especially once they gain fame. they can pay others to do it for them. taylor would rather control it and thats the true element of being an ARTIST. creating ART. talent is only a minor element of the artist realm.

    ________________________________

    Okay I’m joining in on this conversation.

    First post, learn how to spell. Second post Please get out of Taylor’s ass. Not EVERY other artist out their is auto-tuned. There are plenty of artists out their who aren’t auto-tuned and who can actually sing live with out any help at all. Yes there are artists out their who are auto-tuned like Taylor but not ALL of them. Their are plenty of artists out their with real singing talent.

    There are also plenty of other artists out their who write their own music and take part in planning and developing their own tours and have a part in what goes on with their management ect. Taylor Swift isn’t the first one to do all of that. There are plenty of other artists who create ART.

  • Anonymous

    ADMIT TAYLOR FANS the grammy performance was a complete fail.

    Last year when she sang with Miley it sounded better.

    Taylor’s voice has at high pitchy voice that she has no control over. She needs a voice lesson and a vocal coach

  • Billythekid-NY

    Someone mentioned that at least Taylor sounded better at last years Grammy’s. I disagree with this entirely. She messed up vocally as well as once with her guitar on that duet with Miley. But as one blogger online pointed out, no one really paid any attention to it since she wasn’t in the process of winning 4 Grammy’s that night, let alone 1 for best album of the year. That said, it still doesn’t subtract from the fact that Taylor can write well, and does sound good on radio/cd’s. Not everyone sounds good live. Even Miley, who usually sounds decent live, has on occasional sounded not well. Everyone has their days. Not everyone can hit high notes. Miley can’t hit high notes at all really, but the ones she can hit, she kills. Taylor, like Miley, just needs to stay within their range. But not remembering what notes to sing, that’s another story, and a most unfortunate one on Grammy night.

  • Anonymous

    I can understand her record boss to try to defend Taylor, but why does this guy shoot at everything that moves and diss AI, the other Grammy performers etc. etc. Insulting other people will not help.
    He should just say they had technical problems and Taylor was over exited and not at her best etc.

  • Anonymous

    i like those too. but since i wasn’t born in those days i couldn’t listen to them on the radio. haha i USED to love mariah carey. she used to have amazing meaningfull lyrics with great melodies and such an amazing voice. now her music is new R&B crap and she can’t even sing anymore. she used to stand out from all those pop/R&B singers until she sold out to sell because the kinda music she did wasn’t popular anymore. and it always pissed me off how ppl like madonna were more successfull than her. i just don’t like entertainers. is all about the music for me.

  • Anonymous

    At last year’s she sounded less off key. But shit that stinks slightly less is still shit. Taylor was better than Miley that night, but since then, Miley’s performances have seem to have gotten stronger(not a huge fan, but credit where credit is due), where Taylor’s get weaker and weaker. Taylor’s ACM performance was horrid, while Miley’s was not great, but adequate. Miley has a voice, uncontrolled as it may be, and Taylor has none.

  • musiciseverything

    Old school Mariah Carey kicked ass. The 90’s was her decade. Now she sucks. She has turned into this whore machine. She seems to scream in her songs now. And her songs are stupid. For example Obsessed. What the fuck is that shit? That’s not music.

  • purplekoolaid

    talent is only a minor element of the artist realm.

    ——————-
    idiotic statements like this is why people like soulja boy are famous and why I no longer listen to pop radio.

    how can you seriously say that talent is not that important when it comes to being an artist?!?! Do you realize how stupid that sounds! Taylor Swift CANNOT sing. end of story. She can write a catchy song. She should be a songwriter. Not a singer. The end.

  • Billythekid-NY

    Wait a minute. what’s this about Taylor’s dad investing 1 million in her label in order for them to sign her? Not really up on Taylor’s history, but I certainly wasn’t aware of her family being rich like that BEFORE she hit it big. I’d have to check on that before I’d accept it as fact. Just never heard it mentioned anywhere before.

  • Anonymous :)

    as i’ve said on multiple occasions, swift should be a songwriter at most. singing isn’t for her.

  • Anonymous :)

    as i’ve said on multiple occasions, swift should be a songwriter at most. singing isn’t for her.

  • meli:]!!

    Anonymous said:

    It’s just sad because she can’t sing. If she could there’d be less venom. But people are tired of being taken for a ride. I can accept a lot of things in live performances. A flat note here and there, fine. Everyone has an off night. Hoarsness, yeah, voices get tired. But singing off key every performances, that’s asking way too much. She’s a singer who can’t sing but has her career because Big Machine couldn’t resist the allure of Scott Swift’s offer. Part of me wonders if the songs are even written by her since she doesn’t have any sense of pitch and can’t tune her guitar.

    ============

    YOU
    ARE
    MY
    HERO

  • Anonymous

    Taylor’s family is loaded. Her dad made a killing off their Christmas tree farm. I think he worked for Merril Lynch too. I think PR just likes to romanticize the story. Little girl walking door to door with a demo sounds much better than daddy’s little princess paid for her record deal.

  • A Taste of Honey

    Taylor swift songs aren’t even catchy, actually. Catchy = Soulja boy, Lady Gaga, rihanna, stuff like that.

  • idgam

    i know! sex sells… catchy tunes with crappy lyrics sells. she sold out. i still listen to her old songs. one of the newer songs that i actually listen to is “i wish you well”. new alternative etc. rock sucks as well. and alot of the rock bands sold out as well. and im saying this because oldschool R&B and any type of rock is what i most listen to. but just oldschool. hip-hop is absolute CRAP! is all about “shake your ass girl” kinda shit.

  • Anonymous

    It’s a well-known fact that her family has been loaded since way before she was famous. And actually, it was closer to 2 million. They owned the Christmas tree farm in Wyomissing, their house in Nashville (purchased when they moved there when she was like 13, so she was not famous yet) is HUGE and on a lake, and her first car (also pre-fame) was a brand new Mercedes.

  • Anonymous

    Taylor Swift’s boss is an idiot. And I’m almost positive the American Idol slam was a dig at Carrie Underwood, since she is Taylor’s competition. Taylor Swift cannot sing at all. She is tone deaf. That was pretty much proven on Sunday night. She’s nice. Great, give her an award for being Miss Congeniality. She’s pretty. Miss America. She’s a good role model. Give her a the medal of honor, but don’t give her a damn Grammy because she cannot sing.

  • jazylin

    hey YOU third person !

    YOU are tooo MUCh of “PLENTY” !?

  • Anonymous

    Right. Two million. And 500,000 for the recording of her first album. Really, there’s not much else to explain her record deal. She is tone deaf. Anyone with working ears will hear it.

  • Anonymous

    Am I the only one forgetting that most people used to say that about Kelly in her first 2 or 3 years after Idol? That’s the ONLY reason Kelly is famous, Taylor actually WORKED for it.

  • idgam

    i like ur demi icon. never seen it before!
    that girl actually has talent. i really can’t wait for her to leave disney so they can stop pushing her back.

  • Anonymous

    Not to mention that Kelly sang TAYLOR’S SONG AT HER CONCERT!!!!! Come on now!

  • I am who i am whatever that means

    Taylor Swift’s boss is an idiot. And I’m almost positive the American Idol slam was a dig at Carrie Underwood, since she is Taylor’s competition. Taylor Swift cannot sing at all. She is tone deaf. That was pretty much proven on Sunday night. She’s nice. Great, give her an award for being Miss Congeniality. She’s pretty. Miss America. She’s a good role model. Give her a the medal of honor, but don’t give her a damn Grammy because she cannot sing.
    ________
    Well said my friend, well said

  • Anonymous

    Taylor swift can’t sing for shit
    ___________________________________

    Name one country start besides carrie underwood how can

  • Anonymous

    of course T swift CANT SING!!!!!
    she can’t even sing on TUNE!

    AND KELLY C. SAID SHE BUYS T SWIFTS ALBUMS SO THAT SHE DOESNT SERIOUSLY GET SLAMMED FOR STATING THE FACTS ABOUT TAYLOR.

  • Anonymous

    Bitch is horrible at singing she is overrated and now people are really starting to notice because some of the awards she has are well more deserved by other artist jmo.Even though kayne is an ass sometimes it was not right he wasn’t nominated because of her he is a good artist.I was a fan but damn she is not all that and her boss just made it worse with his happy ass.

  • musiciseverything

    This is very true. Good job.

  • lovatocyrusjonaslove

    I second that!

  • Anonymous

    The Empress has no clothes.

  • Anonymous

    Not everybody likes Miley’s voice, I have nothing against that. But saying Taylor sounded better at the Grammys last year than Miley just shows lack of musical hearing ability, and I say this as musician. Taylor was not on pitch! She was constantly searching the right notes, her voice was oscillating. Miley was mostly on pitch with maybe one or two misses, but then it is not her song. They girl has a unique voice, but she hits the right notes.
    In summary, Miley completely pawned Taylor in that performance.

    e.g compare 2:15-2:25 and 2:25-2:35.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z7vnkMeqNAU

    To say it in Mileys words, opinions are like noses, everybody has one. In my opinion, Taylor voice sounds so shaky because she is not confident enough in her singing to hit the right notes. Miley belts it and she knows she hit the right notes most of the time.

  • Anonymous

    Reba McEntire, Martina McBride, Dolly Parton, Leann Rimes, Hillary Scott(of Lady Antebellum), Kellie Pickler(she’s actually not terrible), Mallory Hope(I believe her name is), Miranda Lambert. Need I go on?

  • Anonymous

    I’m just fed up with people equating being talented with being a role model. Janis Joplin was fucked up 1000 ways from Sunday, but damn if she wasn’t talented. Elvis, same. John Lennon, the list goes on. Granted they weren’t teen entertainers but I think it holds. How “good” you are as a person has zero to do with your God given talent, or lack thereof.

  • Anonymous

    taylor can write.. but she writes about the same thing in all her songs. and she can’t sing for shit. her songs aren’t even catchy. which i don’t even care because i don’t listen to songs just because they’re catchy.
    i just listen to old school music now. new music is CRAP! talent doesn’t even matter now adays which pisses me off. talented singers are puched to the side while ppl like britney, ke$ha etc. are/made it big.

  • Anonymous

    Yeah because she likes taylor ,but she felt she had to step up because taylor boss made her seem all high and mighty.People can be nice but when you start a fire you better be ready to get your ass burned.Besides she is stating facts there’s nothing wrong with that.

  • musiciseverything

    Holy fuck. I love you. I complete agree. Old music is so much better than new music because it actually meant something. Still wondering how Ke$ha made it big.

  • Anonymous

    I’d really like to know how she managed to sound at least decent at the 2009 Grammys while she sounded like a cat being strangled ever since. It’s not a duet issue, since she literally killed the duet she did with Nicks. Speaking of which, did Stevie Nicks lose a bet?

  • Anonymous

    i’d rather my idol make none catchy yet meaningful/deep/beautiful melody music and that can actually sing and not sell out to catchy tunes and not as popular and succesful. i like MUSIC! not the crap that is out today. i don’t listen to the radio like i used to in the 90’s. success doesn’t equal talent.

  • idgam

    thank you. idk what happened to music. it has no meaning now. is all about catchy tunes with crappy lyrics and horrible singers. i miss the 90’s. I LOVE oldschool music.

  • mojo

    Who the hell is Kelly Clarkson to talk? She is famous for winning a glorified karaoke contest. If she had any talent or skills, she would have made a name for herself on her own like Taylor did, with talent and charm and hard work, not relying on a friggin contest to get your name out there.

  • Chelsea-Rose

    I actually happy that this is happening. I love Taylor, she is the sweetest person, and her songs kick ass, but she is a little bad at live singing. I’m glad people are starting to speak out on that.

  • Anonamas

    That lady really needs to learn what a ‘heated discussion’ is.

  • Anonymous

    WOOHOO!!! Go Kellyy!!! Love that girl.. my favorite AI winner, and she tells it like it is! At least someone has the guts to do it..

  • Anonymous

    i love kelly and american idol. they are the best in the world. i don’t like taylor. she can’t sing live with high notes.
    ba ha ha ha …

  • iFail2Much

    She totally owned his ass.

  • Anonymous

    TAYLOR SWIFT SUCKS

  • Anonymous

    haha way to go Kelly, you’re amazing!!

  • Anonymous

    I like Kelly but she has had some bad days as well. I remember one performance at the VMAs where she was all out of tune. And Kelly yells a lot of her lyrics. She is the last one to talk. Taylor is not the best singer, but singing is only one dimension of a superstar. A lot of artist dont sound good live. Look at Madonna, she cannot eally sing yet she is one of the biggest superstars ever. And Miley doesnt have a great voice and Demi does, but who sells more records? Need I answer that????

  • meli:}!!

    I am who i am w… said:

    I’m just fed up with people equating being talented with being a role model. Janis Joplin was fucked up 1000 ways from Sunday, but damn if she wasn’t talented. Elvis, same. John Lennon, the list goes on. Granted they weren’t teen entertainers but I think it holds. How “good” you are as a person has zero to do with your God given talent, or lack thereof.
    _____________
    I love you! you took these words right out of mouth. I was watching a debate yesterday about this and a woman said and i quote ” she may not be a good singer but she a good role model”…and i was like what being a role model has nothing to do with your ability to sing and shouldn’t be in the same sentence! Give a her medal for being a role model but when it comes to grammies give it to people who can actualy sing.

    ==========
    I could not agree with you both more.

  • Anonymous

    the girl had a great year. they all just need 2 back off and let her enjoy her win jeez! if they wanna be mad at someone be mad at the industry people that picked her. those people who pick her 2 win those categories should get the backlash not her. its not her fault she won. she just a kid doing what she loves 2 do writing songs that she relates 2, people r loving it hence why she sells so many albums she may not have the best vocals but she must be doing something rite cuz she selling more than any of these people bashing her. i wonder if people realize the more they hate on her the more she seems to sell. i think it unfair for people 2 think its ok 2 attack her just cuz she is succeeding she works just as hard as the people who think they have the rite 2 hate on her. i think its save 2 say that they all know it takes more than talent 2 make it in hollywood you need that it factor that make people like you and wanna see more of you. hence y miley is famous not demi hence why kesha is killing on the charts her rebel attitude intrigues people + her catchy lyrics its why even selena is selling more than demi she a sweetheart so people wanna see her succeed hence why even though she doesn’t have the best vocals people still give her a shot + she has catchy songs even people who hate her admit they like some of her songs same with miley i know people who hate her but can’t help loving pitusa

  • Anonymous

    yh shes not saying anything cuz she is gonna go cry and write a song about it.. haha

  • Chloeeeeeeeeee

    Team Kelly!

    Brochetta is a jackass. I understand defending your artist. That is fine, but to tear down other Idol winners in the process is tacky, unprofessional & unnecessary. I love me some swifty, but she was “Painfully out of tune”. As Kelly said Everyone has their bad days, you just gotta suck it up & get over it!

  • Anonymous

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zg9MyYqzlos

    Probably should’ve figured out she was tone deaf after this. There’s off nights, and there’s being tone deaf.

  • brianaheart19

    I like Taylor. She’s a good songwriter. But she can’t sing. Honestly I even think Miley was a better singer. And I didn’t Miley was that good of a live singer until last year.

  • brianaheart19

    Wait take that back. I think she can sing just not that good

  • Chloeeeeeeeeee

    Oh & I still can’t belive Taylor won best Female Country VOCAL over Carrie Underwood! The faaaack?! Srsly.

  • Chloeeeeeeeeee

    Double post. =|

  • dmimima

    Lmao, Oceanup comments are hilarious.
    But I agree with most of you, Taylor Swift can not sing. She writes good relatable lyrics, but besides she’s not all that talented. I’m sorry. I like her music, as much as the next person, but she is getting extremely overrated. Her performance was horrible, but then again all her live performances are.

    Kelly has the guts to stick up for AI. She’s also probably pissed that a twerp like Taylor Swift is winning grammys instead of the real talented people. I know I was.

  • YouBelongWithMe

    Haters flush yourself in a toilet
    I understand Taylor is not the best singer
    there is no such thing
    Taylor has to work more on her vocals and that is what a musician is about
    Over the years they get better and better
    Your job is not to criticize her voice because you probably can’t even sing better than her

  • Tru

    I totally agree with Kelly. I love Taylors music but since the beginning I thought she couldn’t sing. She has gotten better which I will give her credit for that. The people from American Idol are great singers no matter what anyone says.

  • I am who i am whatever that means

    Taylor swift can’t sing for shit
    ___________________________________

    Name one country start besides carrie underwood how can
    _______
    I’m not the first person but will respond to the question: Keith Urban, Bran Paisley, Miranda etc oh wait that was more than one!

  • ellie

    seriously some of these comments are pathetic if taylor swift had no place in the music industry then why is she turning over $18million a year selling out tours and winning grammys….and yes she was doing extremely well before the kanye incident so that has NOTHING to do with her fame…she wouldnt be in the music industry if she didnt deserve to be :D and in my eyes she 100% does ! she made it by herself and didnt even need american idol to do so like kelly clarkson did :D taylor has pure talent in every way! kelly clarkson sucks at some performances and taylor swift is way bigger than kelly clarkson :D GO TEAM TAYLOR!

  • Anonymous

    That fairy dust sprinkled on Taylor Swift to create her image is otherwise known as millions of dollars.

  • Angel

    When you compare both Kelly Clarkson and Taylor Swift together, Kelly Clarkson has a way stronger vocal than Taylor. BUT they’re both very successful and I think Kelly wasn’t happy with Big Machine Records, not Taylor Swift. Kelly’s comment was purely towards the label bashing American Idol.

    Either way, they’re successful like I said, all this bashing eachother will probably go on, just thought i’ve give my opinion.

    Even though Kelly Clarkson is my idol, I love both Taylor and Kelly. There’s no doubt that they both have talent. They’re two different singers, and no one can blame them.

  • Y0URL0VEISMYDRUG

    She seems like a nice girl but she better enjoy this because I have a feeling that by the time she puts out her next album no one will buy it.She is getting so much hate for this.

  • Anonymous

    haha I love kelly
    hate taylor i used to like her but now shes so overrated now i still like her songs though but she shudnt have won that award
    kelly is awsome!
    loved her since ‘since u’ve been gone’ well actually when her breakaway album was released which was wen i was in middle school

  • heybrittanyxo

    Holy fuck. I love you. I complete agree. Old music is so much better than new music because it actually meant something. Still wondering how Ke$ha made it big.
    ——————
    I agree with you Ke$ha should be thanking auto tune cause my friend has the CD the whole thing is auto tuned and her songs are stupid as hell, anyways yes Taylor not a good singer she always has bad performances and people that say she sounds good in concert well so does Britney but they edit her voice too

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous
    Feb 5, 2010 @ 11:03 am
    Anonymous said:

    I worship you Kelly for this comment. Taylor like JB in 08, and most likely Justin Beiber as well, is nothing more than a “novelty” right now. She has her success and that will be it, by her next album no one will care anymore because people will finally realize how much she sucks. The only tweener that has been successfully consistent is Miley.

    _________________________________

    AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. i almost just peed laughing. you do realize that EVERYTHING you said is incorrect right?

    if jb was a flash in the pan then why are they still so unfortunately popular? justin doesn’t look like he’ll be going anywhere for a while. he seems sorta like the new jesse mccartney. and taylor’s success will only grow. she has won numerous accolades for her work and it isn’t about how you SING. it’s about what you SING. look at some of the most famous singers of all time. half of them talk rather than sing. half of them practically scream. the fact isn’t in the talent, its in how the voice aligns with the type of music, lyrics, message, etc. and taylor has it nailed. so sorry you don’t understand that, but she will certainly have people buying her next record.

    also, nothing about miley has been consistent. that might have been the funniest part of your statement. she was a disney cookie cutter princess as hannah. tried to break out. half failed. amped up the sex factor, only wears short shorts and humps the stage/pole dances for attention. her voice has mildly improved but she relies heavily on autotune microphones even in live performance. you can easily hear the synthed quality. not to mention her little NINE YEAR OLD SISTER is making a fricken lingerie line for kids. nothing about her or her family is okay and/or consistent.

  • jazylin

    Oh Good Anonymous.. good job u totally slammed the bad Anonymous who talked shit about tay and praised miley??? HA HAAH AH !

    the 1st Anonymous is a loser!
    taylor will RULE FOREVER!

  • …???….

    People like Taylor’s music b/c of her songwriting skills.
    People like Miley’s music b/c she’s a great entertainer.
    People like Selena’s music b/c it’s Selena.
    Demi seems to be the only one who sells cd’s b/c of her real singing abilities.

  • Anonymous

    People like Taylor’s music b/c of her songwriting skills.
    People like Miley’s music b/c she’s a great entertainer.
    People like Selena’s music b/c it’s Selena.
    Demi seems to be the only one who sells cd’s b/c of her real singing abilities.

    ——————

    AMEN. you are exactly right and it’s what i’ve been trying to say. there are different aspects to fame. and none of these girls have it all. none are consistent. and demi is really the only one with a solid live performance voice. but all have an ELEMENT that make them succeed.

  • Anonymous

    abbey
    Feb 5, 2010 @ 11:14 am
    abbey said:

    Everyone that is defening her is just saying stuff like, well she can sing live in concerts just fine. It’s called auto tuning! They can do that to microphones in concerts you know. That’s why at EVERY SINGLE live performance you hear her on she sounds so bad because it isn’t auto tuned.

    But of course fans that are so far up taylors ass just keep denying it.

    ____________________-

    you’re also hilarious. hope you realize that every artist out there is equally auto-tuned so your argument has no purpose. there is still something to be said in the fact that she micromanages her entire career. writes her own music, manages her own tours, EVERYTHING. most singers do very little especially once they gain fame. they can pay others to do it for them. taylor would rather control it and thats the true element of being an ARTIST. creating ART. talent is only a minor element of the artist realm.

  • GildedButterfly55

    lmao it is true credit were credit is due and That performance was not good, “we not only hit the high notes,we hit the right notes” thats funny.

  • Anonymous

    I’m so glad people are finally starting to realize that Taylor can’t sing. Besides all of the teenies and taylor fans on this site, she’s getting a lot of hate on twitter, E!, and other comment boards from people other then teenies.

    It seems like more and more people are starting to get sick of her.

    Thank god

    —————————————-

    Agreed. I actually have both of her CD’s but at this point I am officially over her. We’re the same age, yet she still thinks that she’s 15 – she needs to grow up and stop talking about how boys screwed he over in high school. And ya, she CAN’T sing. Her voice is so mediocre it’s not even funny. Even on her CD, I can sing along with her and I actually sound better. Thanks to fucking Kanye West, everyone is kissing her ass…..people need to wake up and realize that she has NO PLACE in the music industry.

  • Anonymous

    I’m so glad people are finally starting to realize that Taylor can’t sing. Besides all of the teenies and taylor fans on this site, she’s getting a lot of hate on twitter, E!, and other comment boards from people other then teenies.

    It seems like more and more people are starting to get sick of her.

    Thank god

  • Anonymous

    it just pisses me off how is all about being an entertainer with catchy songs. talent doesn’t matter. these teenagers. why do they like these???

  • Anonymous

    tbh i dont think taylors performance was THAT bad. yeh she isnt the best singer but she is an amazing song writer. kelly may be a better singer than taylor but she isnt as successful as taylor and that says something. taylor doesnt have the strongest voice but she doesnt have a BAD voice either. i think she sounds alot better in other live performances. people should cut her some slack, i dont think half of you could stand up at the grammys and sing.

  • HeyYouOkayNot

    First ?!

  • …???….

    Apparently not everyone agrees with you guys. You can say what you want but she did sell millions of her album. She may not be great at singing but nowadays that’s not the requirement for winning an award.

  • ERIN

    FIRST!!!!!!!!

  • meli:}!!

    Anonymous said:

    This is just another instance of a spoiled rich kid getting whatever she wants because of her family’s money. Do people really think that if she came from a middle class background, she would have the career she does today? She probably wouldn’t even have a record deal, let alone 4 Grammys.

    ============
    if it wasnt for her milking her break up with joe jonas and the Kanye situation no one would even know the color of her hair. Publicity, good or bad, is still publicity

  • Anonymous

    I’ve known about Taylor since her first album, but she only gained mainstream notoriety after her relationship/break-up with Joe.

  • HeyYouOkayNot

    Yay ! my first time being first!!!!
    horray for me !!!
    hahaha xD I’m lame xD

  • ERIN

    SECOND!!!!

  • Anonymous

    Does anyone remember Milli Vannili?

  • hpaddictedx

    Goo Kelly.

  • Anonymous

    FIFTH!

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous said:

    There are so many talented people who go under the radar, so many amazing albums that came out this year, but this heaping helping of mediocrity gets 4 awards, including the biggest prize of the night? Bullshit. Honestly, I’m shocked that she has a successful headlining tour. Who would want to listen to her off-key wailing for two and a half hours?!

    ==========

    FUCKK! i know!

  • ERIN

    SIXTH!!!!! WOO

  • ERIN

    SEVENTH YAAAAA BOY

  • meli:]!!

    At last year’s she sounded less off key. But shit that stinks slightly less is still shit. Taylor was better than Miley that night, but since then, Miley’s performances have seem to have gotten stronger(not a huge fan, but credit where credit is due), where Taylor’s get weaker and weaker. Taylor’s ACM performance was horrid, while Miley’s was not great, but adequate. Miley has a voice, uncontrolled as it may be, and Taylor has none.

    ============
    but comparing Taylor swifts singing to mileys isnt saying much :/

  • Nobody Does It Better xx

    I like Taylor but honestly her grammy performance was just terrible.
    I thought people were just being mean about it.
    & You go Kelly!

  • meli:]!!

    honestly the GRAMMYS are a joke. its becoming another show based on popularity contest.

  • Anonymous

    well done kelky

  • britt

    hahahahahhahahahhahahah…
    I just find this completely hilarious
    hahahahahhahaahahahaaha

  • Mercedes

    uh-oh i’m the title grabbed my attention