If Jrdin is supporting Demi great, but you know the comments on OU will be "Better than Demi". Anon already said it like they had an itchy trigger finger. And she sounds beautiful, Demi's version has a haunted quality to it like it was coming from a very dark place, which I like and appreciate.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:24 pm
Anonymous said:
That was nice
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:24 pm
Lovatic#1! said:
Demi's new song "Skyscraper is a hit already I'm so proud of Demi and the work she is doing on her album.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:25 pm
Anonymous said:
Much better
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:26 pm
Anonymous said:
I LOVE IT
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:26 pm
Anonymous said:
How can you say one is better than the other, they sound exactly the same for me :l
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:27 pm
Lovatic#1! said:
Better than Demi
-----------
Demi recored "Skyscraper" when she was in rehab her thoart was damaged.
i actually think i like DEmi's better ....
A lot of people were saying Jordin would sing it better ... yea they were wrong
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:30 pm
Anonymous said:
Hate her.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:30 pm
Lovatic#1! said:
I gotta admit Jordan sounded good but since this is demi's song and her single that number 1 on iTunes i gotta give Demi some credit it's her song.Demi's cover is better
Better than Demi
-----------
Demi recored "Skyscraper" when she was in rehab her thoart was damaged.
----
Please, you do not need to make excuses for her. In fact imperfections in her voice plus her raw emotion is what make the song rise above the other crap out there. Jrdin's sound quality may be smoother, but the story being told is represented by Demi's vocals.
I like the rawness and emotion in Demi's version better. And when Jordin sang the chorus, it was kind of shaky but both versions are good. (:
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:36 pm
Anonymous said:
Yeah, honestly if this was sung by Jordin and she released it, I wouldn't have bought it. Demi's vocals were much better, even with her damaged vocal chords and there was so much emotion to it. This was just bleh :/
I think both versions are amazing. Since it's Demi's song I personally find it better. Plus, you can hear the emotion in her voice. Jordin Sparks is amazing as well and I do love this cover but if you choose to compare, Demi I believe out shined Jordin. Which is fine seeing as how it is Demi's song.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:43 pm
Anonymous said:
Please, you do not need to make excuses for her. In fact imperfections in her voice plus her raw emotion is what make the song rise above the other crap out there. Jrdin's sound quality may be smoother, but the story being told is reprenentedby Demi's vocals
------
Im a Lovatic I should know nice try but thanks for the correction.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:44 pm
Anonymous said:
Really looks like Jordin is trying to steal some of Demi's spotlight because of what Skyscraper did for Demi's career.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:44 pm
Anonymous said:
The song wasn't Demi's to begin with. Jordin recorded the song first and gave it to Demi. That's why Jordin's background vocals are on still Demi's version.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:48 pm
Anonymous said:
They both did an awesome job!
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:49 pm
Anonymous said:
Jordin has always had a better voice than all these Disney stars. Miley sounds like she's been smoking cigarettes for years. Selena's not that great and all hype and Demi is so raspy she sounds like she has pieces of glass in her throat.
Great job by Jordin but it doesn't have the same emotion that Demi's has. Considering what she's been through, no one will top the way Demi sings this song.
Wow.. now that I think about it.. this song actually sounds more like a Jordin type song than a Demi type song..
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:58 pm
Anonymous said:
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:44 pm
Anonymous said:
Really looks like Jordin is trying to steal some of Demi's spotlight because of what Skyscraper did for Demi's career.
---
you never heard of anyone doing a cover? shut the fuck up.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 08:01 pm
Anonymous said:
obviously jordin has an incredible voice
and i do feel the emotion in it jordin did it justice probably the best cover of the song ive heard
BUT something about demis version screams pain and i love that about it and i dont feel that any cover has mastered that yet
Jul 18, 2011 @ 08:02 pm
Anonymous said:
demi is better, but jordan is good too.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 08:04 pm
Anonymous said:
Really looks like Jordin is trying to steal some of Demi's spotlight because of what Skyscraper did for Demi's career.
I agree
Jul 18, 2011 @ 08:05 pm
Anonymous said:
nonymous said:
Really looks like Jordin is trying to steal some of Demi's spotlight because of what Skyscraper did for Demi's career.
I agree
just kidding i was agreeing with myself.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 08:05 pm
Anonymous said:
Anonymous said:
Jordin has always had a better voice than all these Disney stars. Miley sounds like she's been smoking cigarettes for years. Selena's not that great and all hype and Demi is so raspy she sounds like she has pieces of glass in her throat.
--
Are you fucking better than any of them? Then you shouldn't be talking. Demi recorded the song before treatment when she was purging & she was crying while recording it. Yeah that's your option but just keep the negativity to yourself, please.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 08:10 pm
Anonymous said:
sweet !
Jul 18, 2011 @ 08:19 pm
Anonymous said:
Calm all your asses down. Like who cares if some people say Jordin's version is better? It's just their opinion. Just like you little fuckers say your opinion that demi's version is better. So all the people saying that are fighting to the people that said Demi's version is better. Just STFU and let everyone state their opinion. It's not a bad thin or anything. At least they're not saying bad things about Demi. Demi and Jordin's
versions are both good and everyone can have a opinion, so shut the fuck up you little bitches and just enjoy the cover.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 08:20 pm
Anonymous said:
oddly enough, although i would normally like jordin's voice better, i genuinely like demi's version better. 5
Calm all your asses down. Like who cares if some people say Jordin's version is better? It's just their opinion. Just like you little fuckers say your opinion that demi's version is better. So all the people saying that are fighting to the people that said Demi's version is better. Just STFU and let everyone state their opinion. It's not a bad thin or anything. At least they're not saying bad things about Demi. Demi and Jordin's
versions are both good and everyone can have a opinion, so shut the fuck up you little bitches and just enjoy the cover.
--- Rawr.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 08:28 pm
Anonymous said:
Nice i really loved Christina Grimmie's version too
Um to the idiot that said that Jordin is trying to steal Demi's spotlight, can I just say that you are a fucking idiot. In case you all weren't aware, Demi did NOT write the song. Jordin demoed the song way before Demi, but decided not to record it. And they even kept Jordin's bg vocals on Demi's track. If anything, she's showing her support for Demi by "covering" it.
I prefer Jordin's version. I wish she would have recorded her cover in the studio like Ariana Grande does...as a matter of fact, I'm almost certain Ariana will record her mix on this. I love the song itself, but I just cannot with Demi's vocals on it. They are so strained & forced. I understand her voice was damamged, but she could have re-recorded it at a later time....she sounds weak, vulnerable, and sqeaky as hell. I find it annoying to be quite honest
OMFG I JUST READ THAT KERLI WROTE THIS SONG!!!!I LOVER HER
Jul 18, 2011 @ 08:59 pm
Anonymous said:
Both girls rocked it for different reasons. Demi's vocals may be questionable but she's clearly very talented and the emotion she conveys is incredible. Jordan's voice is like silk even if it has less meaning. I get that everyone can have their own opinion but there's no need to bash the other to prove why you like one best.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 09:03 pm
Anonymous said:
seriously ppl, Demi's version is studio, Jordin sang it without nething, pure acoustic, so wen Demi sings it live then we can compare!
Both. Until Demi re-records it that ,or does it acoustically. Her voice should be good to go now. lol
Jul 18, 2011 @ 09:12 pm
Anonymous said:
LeaveMeTheFuckAlone said:
Um to the idiot that said that Jordin is trying to steal Demi's spotlight, can I just say that you are a fucking idiot. In case you all weren't aware, Demi did NOT write the song. Jordin demoed the song way before Demi, but decided not to record it. And they even kept Jordin's bg vocals on Demi's track. If anything, she's showing her support for Demi by "covering" it.
-------------------
i know rite! Y wud sum1 who has won idol and sold over 9 million singles worldwide to date want to steal the spotlight from Demi!!! WHY???
Jordin's was better.
I love Jordin better as a singer, and a person so she wins in my book.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 09:15 pm
Anonymous said:
That's why Jordin thanked Demi for keeping her background vocals on it.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 09:22 pm
Anonymous said:
Jordin had the past two hits in her hands. 'Who Says' was hers first. And now 'SkyScraper.' Priscilla (write of Who Says) must've favored Selena and her status to sell the song because I heard they did Jordin dirty by snatching the song last minute after being recorded and everything.
I cant feel Jordins emotion in the song at all. It seemed like she was trying to force emotion. Im a fan of Jordin but I lost some respect for her when she released I am women as her single.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 09:53 pm
Anonymous said:
Like hers better... And btw it's not number 1 anymore not even the video.
I feel like Jordin's voice is almost to perfect for the song. Like Demi vocal imperfections shows all the vulnerabilities and issues that song is talking about.
I love it her voice is soo amazing can listen to this all day
Jul 18, 2011 @ 11:29 pm
Anonymous said:
You dumbass clearly you're not a Lovatic or else you would know that Demi recorded Skysraper BEFORE anyone ever even knew about her issues.
Jul 18, 2011 @ 11:30 pm
idkMyBFFjill said:
OMG I wanted her to do this!! She does the backup on Demi's track, doesn't she??
Jul 18, 2011 @ 11:41 pm
LianaTaveras said:
I think both of them did great, but it still is Demi's song and she did it amazingly! and I'm sure Jordin did not did this so people compare her with Demi
Jul 19, 2011 @ 12:08 am
Anonymous said:
Jordin actually had this song first, so I don't know what you little kids are talking about "she's trying to steal the spotlight from Demi because of what it did for her career." Excuse me, Jordin did the vocals on the demo of this song and Demi even left Jordin's backup vocals on the track. Jordin most definitely isn't trying to steal any spotlight from Demi, are other artists not allowed to cover other artists songs? They both did an amazing job with the song.
Jordin did a really good job, but I prefer Demi's version. Demi's voice has so much emotion and rawness in the song that no one can duplicate.
Jul 19, 2011 @ 12:33 am
D said:
Oh my damn. Demi's is great too, but wow @ Jordin. That voice.
Jul 19, 2011 @ 01:31 am
Melissa said:
At first, I couldnt really tell a difference at all in the songs until the bridge of the song.
Jordin sounds sooo good singing this song and I can see her having this as her song but I'm glad she passed it because Demi singing it just gives it something different. Like someone said above, it's haunting. I cant wait to hear an acoustic version of it.
I prefer Demi's simply because of how it fits her better i think and I LOVE her voice. I generally dont like Jordin's music but this gives me a whole new respect for her talent. She sang it beautifully
Jul 19, 2011 @ 01:47 am
Anonymous said:
http://is.gd/bbBdi8 <------ SHOCK! MOTHER WILL MILEY CYRUS! FATHER WHO WILL SEE! SHOCK!
Jul 19, 2011 @ 01:47 am
Anonymous said:
http://is.gd/bbBdi8 <------ SHOCK! MOTHER WILL MILEY CYRUS! FATHER WHO WILL SEE! SHOCK!
Jul 19, 2011 @ 03:45 am
Anonymous said:
I like it to! Jordin is a very good singer! But I like Demi's version of the song more!
Jul 19, 2011 @ 05:59 am
Anonymous said:
http://is.gd/XhEMlp <--- SHOCK! MILEY CYRUS WILL BE MUM! YOU MUST SEE IT!!! SHOCK!
Jul 19, 2011 @ 06:21 am
Anonymous said:
Better than Demi, but Demi's version had more emotion and purpose.
LeaveMeTheFuckAlone said:
I prefer Jordin's version. I wish she would have recorded her cover in the studio like Ariana Grande does...as a matter of fact, I'm almost certain Ariana will record her mix on this. I love the song itself, but I just cannot with Demi's vocals on it. They are so strained & forced. I understand her voice was damamged, but she could have re-recorded it at a later time....she sounds weak, vulnerable, and sqeaky as hell. I find it annoying to be quite honest
---
hater much?
Jul 19, 2011 @ 06:55 am
MARISSAJONAS <3 said:
demi is WAY better, so stfu
Jul 19, 2011 @ 06:55 am
Anonymous said:
Jordin has always had a better voice than all these Disney stars. Miley sounds like she's been smoking cigarettes for years. Selena's not that great and all hype and Demi is so raspy she sounds like she has pieces of glass in her throat.
------
thy puking after every meal...
see what your voice sound like!
Demi did a great job!
Jul 19, 2011 @ 12:08 am
Anonymous said:
Jordin actually had this song first, so I don't know what you little kids are talking about "she's trying to steal the spotlight from Demi because of what it did for her career." Excuse me, Jordin did the vocals on the demo of this song and Demi even left Jordin's backup vocals on the track. Jordin most definitely isn't trying to steal any spotlight from Demi, are other artists not allowed to cover other artists songs? They both did an amazing job with the song.
----
One person said that, chill out. Also it was Karli or however it's spelts(such I should know by now considering I'm her fan too) song not jordans, Jordan just recorded the BG vocals for Demi I believe, I do t know where y'all are getting this it was her song/demi first thing from.
Jul 19, 2011 @ 07:57 am
Anonymous said:
Jordin is singing this through a shitty computer mic and still sounds better than the studio version of this song.
Jul 19, 2011 @ 08:31 am
Anonymous said:
Jordin obviously had the song before her or was in with a chance, they offer songs to people and Demi's name probably appeared and after hearing the rawness in her voice and that haunting quality they thought she was the more convincing and Disney stars can sell singles...
Unfortunatley, I love Jordin, but she hasn't got the best team behind her and she probably wouldn't have got a number 1. However it is arguable would Demi have been number one if she released this before rehab?
Either way both are extremly talented.
Jul 19, 2011 @ 09:24 am
Anonymous said:
im sorry but this is so much better than demi's version
No one can sing it bbetter than Demi... just saying, but Jordin is awesome tho.
Jul 19, 2011 @ 09:50 am
Anonymous said:
woow better than demi =O
Jul 19, 2011 @ 11:54 am
Anonymous1 said:
Better than Demi? heck no.. it was great but no one can sing this song with more emocions than Demi.. Demi sings this with reasons, with expirience left behind.. just think about that.
Jul 19, 2011 @ 12:16 pm
Paula said:
I loved.. but I still like more Demi
Jul 19, 2011 @ 03:17 pm
Anonymous said:
amazing. she sounds really good!!!!!!!
Jul 19, 2011 @ 04:09 pm
Tiffywiffy said:
luved it!!! so much emotion is felt thru her version but i stl luv demi's own 2... love them both.
First
Better than Demi.
demi's is so much better, it has so much more emotion
If Jrdin is supporting Demi great, but you know the comments on OU will be "Better than Demi". Anon already said it like they had an itchy trigger finger. And she sounds beautiful, Demi's version has a haunted quality to it like it was coming from a very dark place, which I like and appreciate.
That was nice
Demi's new song "Skyscraper is a hit already I'm so proud of Demi and the work she is doing on her album.
Much better
I LOVE IT
How can you say one is better than the other, they sound exactly the same for me :l
Better than Demi
-----------
Demi recored "Skyscraper" when she was in rehab her thoart was damaged.
i actually think i like DEmi's better ....
A lot of people were saying Jordin would sing it better ... yea they were wrong
Hate her.
I gotta admit Jordan sounded good but since this is demi's song and her single that number 1 on iTunes i gotta give Demi some credit it's her song.Demi's cover is better
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:27 pm
Lovatic#1! said:
Better than Demi
-----------
Demi recored "Skyscraper" when she was in rehab her thoart was damaged.
----
Please, you do not need to make excuses for her. In fact imperfections in her voice plus her raw emotion is what make the song rise above the other crap out there. Jrdin's sound quality may be smoother, but the story being told is represented by Demi's vocals.
I like the rawness and emotion in Demi's version better. And when Jordin sang the chorus, it was kind of shaky but both versions are good. (:
Yeah, honestly if this was sung by Jordin and she released it, I wouldn't have bought it. Demi's vocals were much better, even with her damaged vocal chords and there was so much emotion to it. This was just bleh :/
http://gifsoup.com/MTM4ODM5MQ
Demi's skscraper is a hit gif time
I think both versions are amazing. Since it's Demi's song I personally find it better. Plus, you can hear the emotion in her voice. Jordin Sparks is amazing as well and I do love this cover but if you choose to compare, Demi I believe out shined Jordin. Which is fine seeing as how it is Demi's song.
Please, you do not need to make excuses for her. In fact imperfections in her voice plus her raw emotion is what make the song rise above the other crap out there. Jrdin's sound quality may be smoother, but the story being told is reprenentedby Demi's vocals
------
Im a Lovatic I should know nice try but thanks for the correction.
Really looks like Jordin is trying to steal some of Demi's spotlight because of what Skyscraper did for Demi's career.
The song wasn't Demi's to begin with. Jordin recorded the song first and gave it to Demi. That's why Jordin's background vocals are on still Demi's version.
They both did an awesome job!
Jordin has always had a better voice than all these Disney stars. Miley sounds like she's been smoking cigarettes for years. Selena's not that great and all hype and Demi is so raspy she sounds like she has pieces of glass in her throat.
just WOOW!!
http://famousplastic.com/2010/06/17/miley-cyrus-got-a-nose-job/
Great job by Jordin but it doesn't have the same emotion that Demi's has. Considering what she's been through, no one will top the way Demi sings this song.
Wow.. now that I think about it.. this song actually sounds more like a Jordin type song than a Demi type song..
Jul 18, 2011 @ 07:44 pm
Anonymous said:
Really looks like Jordin is trying to steal some of Demi's spotlight because of what Skyscraper did for Demi's career.
---
you never heard of anyone doing a cover? shut the fuck up.
obviously jordin has an incredible voice
and i do feel the emotion in it jordin did it justice probably the best cover of the song ive heard
BUT something about demis version screams pain and i love that about it and i dont feel that any cover has mastered that yet
demi is better, but jordan is good too.
Really looks like Jordin is trying to steal some of Demi's spotlight because of what Skyscraper did for Demi's career.
I agree
nonymous said:
Really looks like Jordin is trying to steal some of Demi's spotlight because of what Skyscraper did for Demi's career.
I agree
just kidding i was agreeing with myself.
Anonymous said:
Jordin has always had a better voice than all these Disney stars. Miley sounds like she's been smoking cigarettes for years. Selena's not that great and all hype and Demi is so raspy she sounds like she has pieces of glass in her throat.
--
Are you fucking better than any of them? Then you shouldn't be talking. Demi recorded the song before treatment when she was purging & she was crying while recording it. Yeah that's your option but just keep the negativity to yourself, please.
sweet !
Calm all your asses down. Like who cares if some people say Jordin's version is better? It's just their opinion. Just like you little fuckers say your opinion that demi's version is better. So all the people saying that are fighting to the people that said Demi's version is better. Just STFU and let everyone state their opinion. It's not a bad thin or anything. At least they're not saying bad things about Demi. Demi and Jordin's
versions are both good and everyone can have a opinion, so shut the fuck up you little bitches and just enjoy the cover.
oddly enough, although i would normally like jordin's voice better, i genuinely like demi's version better. 5
Beautiful
Anonymous said:
Calm all your asses down. Like who cares if some people say Jordin's version is better? It's just their opinion. Just like you little fuckers say your opinion that demi's version is better. So all the people saying that are fighting to the people that said Demi's version is better. Just STFU and let everyone state their opinion. It's not a bad thin or anything. At least they're not saying bad things about Demi. Demi and Jordin's
versions are both good and everyone can have a opinion, so shut the fuck up you little bitches and just enjoy the cover.
---
Rawr.
Nice i really loved Christina Grimmie's version too
Um to the idiot that said that Jordin is trying to steal Demi's spotlight, can I just say that you are a fucking idiot. In case you all weren't aware, Demi did NOT write the song. Jordin demoed the song way before Demi, but decided not to record it. And they even kept Jordin's bg vocals on Demi's track. If anything, she's showing her support for Demi by "covering" it.
I love Jordin Sparks
jordin's version
I prefer Jordin's version. I wish she would have recorded her cover in the studio like Ariana Grande does...as a matter of fact, I'm almost certain Ariana will record her mix on this. I love the song itself, but I just cannot with Demi's vocals on it. They are so strained & forced. I understand her voice was damamged, but she could have re-recorded it at a later time....she sounds weak, vulnerable, and sqeaky as hell. I find it annoying to be quite honest
no1curr
I like demis version better. BLEH
jordanING said:
no1curr
-------
bitch, who you talking to??
OMFG I JUST READ THAT KERLI WROTE THIS SONG!!!!I LOVER HER
Both girls rocked it for different reasons. Demi's vocals may be questionable but she's clearly very talented and the emotion she conveys is incredible. Jordan's voice is like silk even if it has less meaning. I get that everyone can have their own opinion but there's no need to bash the other to prove why you like one best.
seriously ppl, Demi's version is studio, Jordin sang it without nething, pure acoustic, so wen Demi sings it live then we can compare!
Both. Until Demi re-records it that ,or does it acoustically. Her voice should be good to go now. lol
LeaveMeTheFuckAlone said:
Um to the idiot that said that Jordin is trying to steal Demi's spotlight, can I just say that you are a fucking idiot. In case you all weren't aware, Demi did NOT write the song. Jordin demoed the song way before Demi, but decided not to record it. And they even kept Jordin's bg vocals on Demi's track. If anything, she's showing her support for Demi by "covering" it.
-------------------
i know rite! Y wud sum1 who has won idol and sold over 9 million singles worldwide to date want to steal the spotlight from Demi!!! WHY???
Jordin's was better.
I love Jordin better as a singer, and a person so she wins in my book.
That's why Jordin thanked Demi for keeping her background vocals on it.
Jordin had the past two hits in her hands. 'Who Says' was hers first. And now 'SkyScraper.' Priscilla (write of Who Says) must've favored Selena and her status to sell the song because I heard they did Jordin dirty by snatching the song last minute after being recorded and everything.
Anonymous said:
Really looks like Jordin is trying to steal some of Demi's spotlight because of what Skyscraper did for Demi's career.
---
I agree
I cant feel Jordins emotion in the song at all. It seemed like she was trying to force emotion. Im a fan of Jordin but I lost some respect for her when she released I am women as her single.
Like hers better... And btw it's not number 1 anymore not even the video.
jordin your amazing !
alive?
Totally love Jordin's version.
DEMI IS BETTER
I feel like Jordin's voice is almost to perfect for the song. Like Demi vocal imperfections shows all the vulnerabilities and issues that song is talking about.
I love it her voice is soo amazing can listen to this all day
You dumbass clearly you're not a Lovatic or else you would know that Demi recorded Skysraper BEFORE anyone ever even knew about her issues.
OMG I wanted her to do this!! She does the backup on Demi's track, doesn't she??
I think both of them did great, but it still is Demi's song and she did it amazingly! and I'm sure Jordin did not did this so people compare her with Demi
Jordin actually had this song first, so I don't know what you little kids are talking about "she's trying to steal the spotlight from Demi because of what it did for her career." Excuse me, Jordin did the vocals on the demo of this song and Demi even left Jordin's backup vocals on the track. Jordin most definitely isn't trying to steal any spotlight from Demi, are other artists not allowed to cover other artists songs? They both did an amazing job with the song.
Jordin did a really good job, but I prefer Demi's version. Demi's voice has so much emotion and rawness in the song that no one can duplicate.
Oh my damn. Demi's is great too, but wow @ Jordin. That voice.
At first, I couldnt really tell a difference at all in the songs until the bridge of the song.
Jordin sounds sooo good singing this song and I can see her having this as her song but I'm glad she passed it because Demi singing it just gives it something different. Like someone said above, it's haunting. I cant wait to hear an acoustic version of it.
I prefer Demi's simply because of how it fits her better i think and I LOVE her voice. I generally dont like Jordin's music but this gives me a whole new respect for her talent. She sang it beautifully
http://is.gd/bbBdi8 <------ SHOCK! MOTHER WILL MILEY CYRUS! FATHER WHO WILL SEE! SHOCK!
http://is.gd/bbBdi8 <------ SHOCK! MOTHER WILL MILEY CYRUS! FATHER WHO WILL SEE! SHOCK!
I like it to! Jordin is a very good singer! But I like Demi's version of the song more!
http://is.gd/XhEMlp <--- SHOCK! MILEY CYRUS WILL BE MUM! YOU MUST SEE IT!!! SHOCK!
Better than Demi, but Demi's version had more emotion and purpose.
Good job, though. Never cease to impress me
LeaveMeTheFuckAlone said:
I prefer Jordin's version. I wish she would have recorded her cover in the studio like Ariana Grande does...as a matter of fact, I'm almost certain Ariana will record her mix on this. I love the song itself, but I just cannot with Demi's vocals on it. They are so strained & forced. I understand her voice was damamged, but she could have re-recorded it at a later time....she sounds weak, vulnerable, and sqeaky as hell. I find it annoying to be quite honest
---
hater much?
demi is WAY better, so stfu
Jordin has always had a better voice than all these Disney stars. Miley sounds like she's been smoking cigarettes for years. Selena's not that great and all hype and Demi is so raspy she sounds like she has pieces of glass in her throat.
------
thy puking after every meal...
see what your voice sound like!
Demi did a great job!
Jul 19, 2011 @ 12:08 am
Anonymous said:
Jordin actually had this song first, so I don't know what you little kids are talking about "she's trying to steal the spotlight from Demi because of what it did for her career." Excuse me, Jordin did the vocals on the demo of this song and Demi even left Jordin's backup vocals on the track. Jordin most definitely isn't trying to steal any spotlight from Demi, are other artists not allowed to cover other artists songs? They both did an amazing job with the song.
----
One person said that, chill out. Also it was Karli or however it's spelts(such I should know by now considering I'm her fan too) song not jordans, Jordan just recorded the BG vocals for Demi I believe, I do t know where y'all are getting this it was her song/demi first thing from.
Jordin is singing this through a shitty computer mic and still sounds better than the studio version of this song.
Jordin obviously had the song before her or was in with a chance, they offer songs to people and Demi's name probably appeared and after hearing the rawness in her voice and that haunting quality they thought she was the more convincing and Disney stars can sell singles...
Unfortunatley, I love Jordin, but she hasn't got the best team behind her and she probably wouldn't have got a number 1. However it is arguable would Demi have been number one if she released this before rehab?
Either way both are extremly talented.
im sorry but this is so much better than demi's version
No one can sing it bbetter than Demi... just saying, but Jordin is awesome tho.
woow better than demi =O
Better than Demi? heck no.. it was great but no one can sing this song with more emocions than Demi.. Demi sings this with reasons, with expirience left behind.. just think about that.
I loved.. but I still like more Demi
amazing. she sounds really good!!!!!!!
luved it!!! so much emotion is felt thru her version but i stl luv demi's own 2... love them both.
Wow, i love Jordin's Voice! :DD
Demi's version is so much better, so much emotional.
COMPLTELY AGREE! like both are AMAZING.. now everyone stfu and enjoy how jordan sings. SMH