• Anonymous
  • Anonymous

    selena sings horrible

  • Anonymous

    Selena was there at the beginning of the video anywayzzzzzs Is that Shakira singing??

  • lacey

    @anonymous, no, that’s not Shakira singing, thats Carly Rae Jepsen!! She is a Canadian singer that Justin Bieber and his manager signed to their record label!

  • BrokenArrow

    Selena definitely looks like she’s having a lot of fun

  • Anonymous

    If she posted it on her “personal” tumblr and it has them all in the video its bound to be found by a follower of hers or found in the tags. Just saying.

  • Anonymous

    haha everyones on hater-adeee but aw ashley looks like shes friendly. i like seeing celebs act like normal people.

  • dracula

    Selena’s not there, but with that terrible stage presence, and that awful voice, I don’t doubt many people mistook Carly Rae with Selena
    —-
    carly rae jepsen has a better voice undoubtably than you have. stop being a jealous hater.

  • Anonymous

    ashley is a famehoeeeeee

  • Anonymous

    Selena is at the very beginning of the video, within the first few seconds which is why some people think that she’s not there. Selena is in the back, and the video is showing Samantha Droke and Ashley.

  • Anonymous

    Selena is at the very beginning of the video, within the first few seconds which is why some people think that she’s not there. Selena is in the back, and the video is showing Samantha Droke and Ashley.

    Its at 0:23 secs, she there for a bit but its hard to see because Ashley is jumping/dancing.

  • Anonymous

    Selena is at the very beginning of the video, within the first few seconds which is why some people think that she’s not there. Selena is in the back, and the video is showing Samantha Droke and Ashley.

    Its at 0:23 secs, she there for a bit but its hard to see because Ashley is jumping/dancing.

  • Anonymous

    selena don’t seem like a fun person to hangout at a party she looks so bored while everyone else is jumping and having fun. Maybe because nobody is paying attention to her.

  • Anonymous

    carly rae jepsen sounds deeper and kinda worse than in the studio version lol, but maybe she was shy and thats why. was the actual song playing in the background too?

  • Anonymous
  • Anonymous

    im happy justin had a real bday party and a good birthday this year like 2010 and unlike 2011.
    btw ashley seems like an attention whore #nothating #justwhatisee

  • an

    she’s not singing worse than all the audience in that bd party… i mean come on… justin bieber, selena gomez, ashley tisdale… hehe

  • Anonymous

    Was this at Justin’s Birthday?

    Selena’s not there, but with that terrible stage presence, and that awful voice, I don’t doubt many people mistook Carly Rae with Selena.

  • Anonymous

    Yes Selena was There! At THE beginning Of THE video..
    She was standing Behind Ashley tisdale and then she leave..
    Guess she’s not in a dancing mood :)

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous said:
    Was this at Justin’s Birthday?
    Selena’s not there, but with that terrible stage presence, and that awful voice, I don’t doubt many people mistook Carly Rae with Selena.
    ——–
    You just can’t stop slashing Selena, can’t you? I guess you’re totally blind not to see her and for hating her so much! So Sad! Really Sad, hater(s)! Other people don’t really care about your comment on stage presence–they still love Selena. They watch Selena perform on stage in her concert tours and yet people still love to listen to her songs. If you hate her so much then why bother coming over to her post to give out disgusting comments! I guess for you it really makes your day if you could slur at Selena every time on Selena’s own post! Pathetic loser(s)! Nobody, except you, will be blind enough to mistake Carly for Selena! They’re obviously two different people! Lol!

  • yeahitsernesto
  • Anonymous

    WOWWW whoever sold this to TMZ and oceanup has nooo life. Ashley posted this on her PERSONAL tumblr and you have to go behind her back for money…. loww

  • Anonymous

    so you think you can sing?

  • Anonymous

    umm, Where exactly did you see Selena in this? I seen Ashley Tisdale dancing with Ryan Good, Carly Rae Jepsen singing the actual song, then i catually see Justin Bieber dancing or having convulsions at @1:40 in the video.. lol jk,, he was having what seems like a good time dancing with his buddy Ryan Good! But here exactly is Selena.. F;alse title, i think..

  • Anonymous

    lol ok Ashley. You can stop now.

  • Anonymous

    Selena is there. -.-
    At the beggining you gotta watch closely shes like in the back, wearing a red dress.

  • Anonymous

    I hate Samantha Drake.

  • Anonymous

    do you really think tis would mind if the vid “leaked”? she’s a famewhore & recently a coattail rider of justin & selena