Selena & Bieber American Idol Judges?

American Idol producer Nigel Lythgoe is to boost the American Idol’s ratings with and wants stars Selena Gomez, Justin Bieber, Pink and Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs as judges, reports RADAR. Mariah Carey, Nicki Minaj and Keith Urban and Randy Jackson will possibly not be returning for season 13.

‘It’s been a lackluster season for Idol and everyone involved with the show is well aware of it so that’s why producers are franticly working on lining up big name stars for season 14. There’s more drama going on behind the scenes of the show than on the stage, and that’s why there’s a major overhaul in the works.

A telling sign was the highlight of the season was Mariah and Nicki’s explosive feud that was leaked on the web, and that was before the season even aired. Producers have been trying to recreate that buzz ever since and it hasn’t worked, the public isn’t buying it. The judges don’t have real chemistry, and there’s no real standout contestant.


That’s why they want to go big next season, you can’t get any bigger than Justin Bieber. The executives are calling it their dream team because who wouldn’t tune in to see Justin and Selena, Pink and Diddy? Pink has been approached in the past and turned it down as well as Diddy, who wanted too much money.


It will cost a fortune to get them, but the show has gotten so stale that Fox is desperate for a revamp, they’re willing to pay to put Idol back on top. Idol is not the water cooler show it used to be, it’s not hip and become really boring.

If producers have it their way, Justin, Selena, Pink and Diddy will be sitting at the judges table next season and that’s a powerhouse group and everyone would tune in to see.’

,

  • Anonymous

    the amount of stupidity u just said is amazing…. FANS not buyers , ppl who like them or at least respect them and i wasnt saying it as a fact dumbass its called making a point

  • Anonymous

    Now that is a joke. Neither can sing live, pink would be fine, but Justin & Selena, no way. That would be pathetic. The show would be even more of a joke than it is now.

  • Anonymous

    Her tour will likely go very well.. She is ADDING dates cause the other dates are selling out. Most performers never add dates, they tend to drop dates. You may not like her, but she has millions of followers, from all age groups.
    ——
    Where is she adding dates?

  • Anonymous

    She added dates to the European leg, just as they were announcing Justin was removing dates, Selena was adding. Justin is likely on his way out due to his antics, Selena is likely to be the next Britney or Madonna, and likely to be far smarter about it (and less crazy) than Britney

  • Anonymous

    Selena should stick to Acting she cant sing well

  • Anonymous

    Selena is the bestest

  • Anonymous

    Selena a judge ? Hahahahaha I wish she would try to judge someone on singing…. Lmao oh god

  • Anonymous

    just end the show already… they should have ended it when they lost paula and simon, when they were still on top. idol’s just a joke now.

  • Anonymous

    lol at ppl saying she cant sing… taylor, katy, britney, austin, lady gaga etc have complimented her on her music/ voice

    i personally think they will make and awesome set of judges

    1. selena and justins fans alone make up 3/4 of the worlds population
    2. p diddy brings gangsta to the show
    3. pink brings awesomeness
    4. selena and justin bring young and new onto the show as well as love <3

    i would DEFINITELY watch idol again if this were the cast

  • Anonymous

    their both on tour so thats not gonna happen. and why the fuck would P Diddy bring viewers?

  • Anonymous

    She added dates to the European leg…..
    ——
    How about a seating capacity for the venues? I know the one has 3500 seats.

    Most likely the next Britney or Madonna. Are you fucking NUTS!!! Honey, she is far, far, far from being like anyone of those two.

  • Anonymous

    p diddy- idk wtf this guy can do, but for one he will bring funny stuff, also bring a different genre

    selena- i think she wont be half bad, she does lack a bit of experience but i mean she will do a decent job, but she is really good at not being pushy and being more supportive and sweet while the other judges may not. also will bring in young viewers and a lot of guys

    justin- he has a lot of experience, he will be a great coach, he will be very honest and his skills will be shown… as a young artist he will be able to relate to,he will have a lot of ideas to bring to the table maybe

    p!nk- i dont think she needs much explaining, she will make very critical and specific remarks, she has a lot of experience in the music industry, but not so much in the judging part so she will be shaky while the other two, im not sure bout diddy but selena and diddy have a little bit of judging backround

    all in all it will bring young, new, lovely,funny and sexy to the show which is what it NEEDS

  • Anonymous

    well true, they r on tour but season 13 hasnt started yet so i mean they still have a chance at it….p diddy i never said he would bring in veiwers i said he would bring gangsta to the show

  • Anonymous

    I really hope this is a BIG joke. I’d take Pink in a heartbeat, but the other three, hell no!!!

  • Anonymous

    I didn’t watch this year and I would NEVER watch if Bieber and Selena are judges. Neither of them have the talent or the experience to be giving anyone advice. The music industry seriously sucks when they think that’s our top talent.

    Selena can’t sing to save her life, she’s HORRIBLE live. Bieber is nothing but a prop.

  • Justinsuglyglasses

    Having Justin and Selena on the panel may bring back the tween fans who abandoned the show after David Archuleta lost in Season 7. David had the crazed teen fans way before Bieber. Remember this memorable fan meltdown moment lol: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHoxl8IK7po

  • Anonymous

    okay I’m sorry but how are selena and justin even QUALIFIED for that? it was bad enough that nicki minaj was a judge. justin would just say “swag” the whole time, and selena isn’t even a good singer so she has no right judging others singing. besides, they’ll probably have busy schedules–touring and i hope selena does another movie. she’s a phenomenal actress and should stick to that :)

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous said:

    lol at ppl saying she cant sing… taylor, katy, britney, austin, lady gaga etc have complimented her on her music/ voice

    Lol, nope.
    Nobody said she’s a great singer.
    Gaga is nice to everybody and she only said LYLALS is good and as much as i love Britney, she’s not the one to discuss vocal talent. I don’t know about Katy and Austin Mahone? Bye.

  • Anonymous

    1. selena and justins fans alone make up 3/4 of the worlds population
    —-
    Can’t take you seriously. Second hand embarrasement. Honey, Selena and Justin would’ve sold 5 billion records if that was the case.

  • BrokenArrow

    How about a seating capacity for the venues? I know the one has 3500 seats.

    Most likely the next Britney or Madonna. Are you fucking NUTS!!! Honey, she is far, far, far from being like anyone of those two.

    I dont think so i asked to one of her fans and told me she was playing in big venues…

  • Anonymous

    If producers have it their way, Justin, Selena, Pink and Diddy will be sitting at the judges table next season and that’s a powerhouse group and everyone would tune in to see.’

    P!nk could say yes.
    Diddy is irrelevant atm.
    Selena whispers to the mic.
    Justin is such a hot mess / big star to being on TV atm.

  • Anonymous

    Shes added 1 date for a 3,500 seat arena

  • Anonymous

    SELENA AND JUSTIN CANT SING!

    PINK IS THE ONLY TALENT

  • Anonymous

    The biggest venue Selena ever played was 22.000, I heard. Her concerts are always 6000-13.000 people.

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous said:

    She added dates to the European leg, just as they were announcing Justin was removing dates, Selena was adding. Justin is likely on his way out due to his antics, Selena is likely to be the next Britney or Madonna, and likely to be far smarter about it (and less crazy) than Britney

    Are you serious?
    Wow. Selenators are so deluded.

  • jennygomez

    of course they do selena is the only one who can save this show

  • jennygomez

    Anonymous said:

    Anonymous said:

    She added dates to the European leg, just as they were announcing Justin was removing dates, Selena was adding. Justin is likely on his way out due to his antics, Selena is likely to be the next Britney or Madonna, and likely to be far smarter about it (and less crazy) than Britney

    Are you serious?
    Wow. Selenators are so deluded.


    selena is already more famous and popular than madonna and britney combined which is why everyone in hollywood is wanting to work with her. if you don’t like it go cry to your flop cyrus poster

  • Anonymous

    STFU LYING.
    Lie to yourself somewhere else.

  • Anonymous

    selena really cant sing live doe.

  • Anonymous

    1. obviously if shes gotten this far and these ppl want her she has singing ability, when she is sitting doen she is actually pretty good
    2. justin lol, yo he can sing. thats just an arguement that u cant win
    3. diddy…. idek whats with this guy, selena brings young and multi talent, justin brings young and experience, pink brings brutal truth and wisdom… p diddy….. idk rap and humor
    4. stfu with the hate, this is a legit crew that can bring in viewers

  • Anonymous

    SHE CANT SING. END OF STORY

  • Anonymous

    They might want to pick singers who can actually sing.

  • threelittlebirds

    american idol has gone downhill since simon and paula left. they honestly should just cancel it, no one will miss it

  • threelittlebirds

    selena is already more famous and popular than madonna and britney combined which is why everyone in hollywood is wanting to work with her. if you don’t like it go cry to your flop cyrus poster
    —–
    is this a joke or? selena hasn’t even come close to achieve as many awards as britney and madonna. take a seat.

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous said:

    the amount of stupidity u just said is amazing…. FANS not buyers , ppl who like them or at least respect them and i wasnt saying it as a fact dumbass its called making a point

    The amount of stupidity YOU just said it’s amazing. Are you seriously idiotic enough to think to 3/4 the population of the world will be tuning American Idol just because they are in the show? Ugh. And I was hoping you were a troll. Stop.

  • Anonymous

    stfu with the hate, this is a legit crew that can bring viewers
    ——
    LMFAO. You need to wake up from your dream world.

  • OCEANUP

    selena has equal vocal ability of britney spears..

  • Anonymous

    Did they really say bigger than Madonna and Britney? Wow selenators are delusional

  • Justinsuglyglasses

    Comparing Selena’s singing to Britney’s? A perfect backhanded compliment OceanUp. Wish I had thought of it lol.

  • Anonymous

    END THE FUCKING SHOW. What’s selena going to tell the contestants? Be an actress in disney then make an album even if you cant fucking sing you’ll get it. Be yourself but that’s not going to sell so copy those that are trending right now. You dont even need to know what your songs are about just perform them with or without passion it will sell but make sure you date or dated a really famous person. Im not even going to start with bieber.

  • Anonymous

    Bigger than Madonna & Britney combined?! Um, not even close…

  • Anonymous

    selena is already more famous and popular than madonna and britney combined which is why everyone in hollywood is wanting to work with her. if you don’t like it go cry to your flop cyrus poster

    Really hope you are trolling.

  • Anonymous

    Overrated. No change.

  • OCEANUP

    come and get ittttttttt

  • Anonymous

    She’s got major back vocals up on this bitch. Seriously, almost sounds like she’s not singing live. Also, SOOO TIIIRREEEDDD of the same dancing every time -.-

  • OCEANUP

    selena wouldn’t even have time to be american idol judge she has too many amazing acting jobs

  • Anonymous

    LMFAO!!!!!!!

  • Anonymous

    they both cant sing
    she is going on tour but that wont go so well
    i dont even know why they would even want her if she cant sing how will she be able to give comments about singing to people who can sing

  • Anonymous

    I’m gonna keep it cute and not drag but…let’s be real Selena isn’t exactly Mariah.

  • Anonymous

    Radar Online…take with a 1 tonne grain of salt. Selena is not likely to have time for this. And to the person that says she isn’t singing live, she has sung it live a number of times, yes she has background singers, news flash, every singer does. Considering you can hear her breathing, or her voice gets muffled when she happens to move certain directions…clear indication of live. And the same dancing is normal, its called a performance. Kinda standard in the pop genre.

  • Anonymous

    Her tour will likely go very well.. She is ADDING dates cause the other dates are selling out. Most performers never add dates, they tend to drop dates. You may not like her, but she has millions of followers, from all age groups.

  • Anonymous

    selena is already more famous and popular than madonna and britney combined which is why everyone in hollywood is wanting to work with her. if you don’t like it go cry to your flop cyrus poster
    ——
    Hey skank, why don’t you tell me who these people are who wanna work with??

    And I never mentioned Miley but since you did selena will always play second fiddle to Miley. Oh yeah and did you know that Miley is Maxim’s #1 Hot 100 of 2013. The only thing that selena is good at is having NO #1’s.

  • Anonymous

    haha sorry but selena is not famous more then madona and britney dont be rediculous madona and britney are famous how you can compare with britney and madona to selena please you make me laugh and hollywood dosent wait for selena thats a lie dont made up things that is not true the only who wait in hollywood is people with real talnlent who can sing and actriz

  • Anonymous

    HAHA SELENA FAMOUS LIKE MADONNA ? HAHA WOW SWEETY WHAT ELSE ARE YOU GONNA INVENTED? YOU ARE SOOOOOOO STUPID

  • Anonymous

    thats make me laugh how can selena be a judge she dosent even know how to sing

  • Anonymous

    Justin being a judge I can understand, but damn Selena?!! Are you kidding me? Girl can’t even sing. I mean she doesn’t suck, but gahhhhhh she’s not a singer!!! Like if she herself audtioned for American Idol, she would get rejected, therefore she has no right to be a judge. She’s trying too hard to be like Cheryl Cole, it’s freaking annoying!

  • Anonymous

    This performance is so boring and repetitive.

  • Anonymous

    I cannot take her seriously, she’s just so average, and this live presentation looks like a gym class high school project… nothing special about it